Polymorphic Pharmaceutical Compounds
Introduction:
The chemical industrial development in pharmaceutical industry is faced with the acceleration of the development time of new medicines and with harmonization guidelines which are required by health authorities for worldwide registration. Polymorphism is the ability of a substance to crystallize into different crystalline forms. These crystalline forms are called polymorphs or crystalline modifications. Polymorphs have the same liquid or gaseous state but they behave differently in the solid-state. The amorphous state is characterized by solidification in a disordered, random manner, structurally similar to the liquid-state. The expression pseudo-polymorphism applies to hydrates and solvates. These three types of solid phases are considered under the term ‘polymorphic behavior’ in this article. Review articles about polymorphism and relevance. Intrinsic properties of a new drug substance candidate are its pKa, its lipophilicity expressed by logP and its intrinsic chemical stability in solutions. Poor physical properties of substances may be changed by using the salt formation in case of acidic or basic compounds and by considering different polymorphs. Formulations are developed to improve solid-state properties and in certain cases affect the solid-state of the drug substance in the drug product. The ‘polymorphic’ behavior of organic substances is driven by thermodynamic and kinetic factors. Therefore several solid phases can coexist. Since the properties of the solid-state may be extremely relevant for the quality of drug products, the International Conference for Harmonization requires a polymorphic study of each new active ingredient with a three-step decision tree starting with detection of different solid phases, followed by the characterization of the different solid phases and if the properties are relevant for the drug product quantitative methods and specifications have to be developed for the drug substance and even for the drug product.
The most relevant property for health authorities is the bioavailability and the bioequivalence of formulation not always correlated with polymorphism, the stability and the robustness of the processes. The processing of the drug substances and drug products involve solvent, temperature and pressure changes as well as mechanical stress and different solid phases may coexist in the drug product. Organic substances show supersaturation behavior and unstable solid phases which should not exist in defined temperature, pressure and humidity may behave like stable forms. These solid metastable phases obtained outside their domains of stability will convert into the thermodynamic stable forms at given temperatures, pressures and relative humidities. These conversions driven by thermodynamic are governed by kinetic and are influenced by impurities, particle size, crystal defects, and presence of seeds. Design of the solid-state is the best choice of the salt candidate and the polymorphic form as early as possible in order to avoid delays due to new development, bioequivalence studies and upscale has to be taken into consideration since synthetic processes will be optimized from the first mg material to the production amount in tons range. For this challenging task, new technologies are now available: high throughput instrumentation, chemometrics, laboratory automation, in line or on line in process analytic have been added to the established high sophisticated technologies such as thermal analysis and calorimetry, X-ray diffraction, spectroscopy and combined techniques. On the other side, predictive computer tools are also available and the two approaches pushed academia and industry to apply better models and better tools in terms of precision and accuracy. Precise knowledge of thermodynamic stability and relationships between different solid phases is a pre-requisite for the manufacture of robust drug substance and drug products. It is also necessary to know the equilibration curves between the solid forms under the influence of the parameters humidity, temperature and pressure in order to predict changes for storage, stability, compatibility and pharmaceutical processes. The major hurdle for the pharmaceutical industry is to have to recall medicines because of polymorphism problems as it was the case for Ritonavir. Strategic development for both salt form and polymorphism are also reviewed. The sensitive quantification methods are needed for the development and are also now required for the monitoring of undesirable solid form(s).
Chemistry, manufacturing, and controls information must be submitted to support the approval of an abbreviated new drug application. This guidance is intended to assist applicants with the submission of ANDAs when a drug substance exists in polymorphic forms. Specifically, this guidance provides:
• FDA recommendations on assessing sameness when the drug substance exists in polymorphic forms.
Decision trees that provide recommendations on monitoring and controlling polymorphs and drug substances and/or drug products.
FDA’s guidance documents, including this guidance, do not establish legally enforceable responsibilities. Instead, guidances describe the Agency’s current thinking on a topic and should be viewed only as recommendations, unless specific regulatory or statutory requirements are cited. The use of the word should in Agency guidances means that something is suggested or recommended, but not required.
II. DEFINITION OF TERMS: POLYMORPHIC FORMS AND POLYMORPHISM
We recommend that ANDA applicants investigate whether the drug substance in question can exist in polymorphic forms. Polymorphic forms in the context of this guidance refer to crystalline and amorphous forms as well as solvate and hydrate forms, which are described below.
• Crystalline forms have different arrangements and/or conformations of the molecules in the crystal lattice.
• Amorphous forms consist of disordered arrangements of molecules that do not possess a distinguishable crystal lattice.
• Solvates are crystal forms containing either stoichiometric or nonstoichiometric amounts of a solvent. If the incorporated solvent is water, the solvate is commonly known as a hydrate.
When a drug substance exists in polymorphic forms, it is said to exhibit polymorphism.
III. GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF PHARMACEUTICAL SOLID POLYMORPHISM
A. Importance of Pharmaceutical Solid Polymorphism
Polymorphic forms of a drug substance can have different chemical and physical properties, including melting point, chemical reactivity, apparent solubility, dissolution rate, optical and mechanical properties, vapor pressure, and density. These properties can have a direct effect on the ability to process and/or manufacture the drug substance and the drug product, as well as on drug product stability, dissolution, and bioavailability. Thus, polymorphism can affect the quality, safety, and efficacy of the drug product.
B. Characterization of Polymorphs
There are a number of methods that can be used to characterize polymorphs of a drug substance.11 Demonstration of a nonequivalent structure by single crystal X-ray diffraction is currently regarded as the definitive evidence of polymorphism. X-ray powder diffraction can also be used to provide unequivocal proof of polymorphism. Other methods, including microscopy, thermal analysis, and spectroscopy are helpful to further characterize polymorphic forms.
C. Influence of Polymorphism on Drug Substance and Drug Product
1. Influence on Solubility, Dissolution, and Bioavailability (BA) and Bioequivalence (BE):
The solid-state properties of a drug substance can have a significant influence on the apparent solubility of the drug substance. Since polymorphic forms differ in their internal solid-state structure, a drug substance that exists in various polymorphic forms can have different aqueous solubilities and dissolution rates. When there are differences in the apparent solubilities of the various polymorphic forms, we recommend that you focus on the potential effect such differences can have on drug product bioavailability (BA) and bioequivalence (BE).
Whether drug product BA/BE can be affected by the differences in apparent solubilities of the various polymorphic forms depends on the various physiological factors that govern the rate and extent of drug absorption including gastrointestinal motility, drug dissolution, and intestinal permeability. In this context, the Biopharmaceutics Classification System provides a useful scientific framework for regulatory decisions regarding drug substance polymorphism.
For a drug whose absorption is only limited by its dissolution, large differences in the apparent solubilities of the various polymorphic forms are likely to affect BA/BE. On the other hand, for a drug whose absorption is only limited by its intestinal permeability, differences in the apparent solubilities of the various polymorphic forms are less likely to affect BA/BE. Furthermore, when the apparent solubilities of the polymorphic forms are sufficiently high and drug dissolution is rapid in relation to gastric emptying, differences in the solubilities of the polymorphic forms are unlikely to affect BA/BE.
Upon demonstration of in-vivo bioequivalence between the generic drug product and the reference listed drug, in-vitro dissolution testing is then used to assess the lot-to-lot quality of the generic drug product. Drug product dissolution testing frequently provides a suitable means to identify and control the quality of the product from both the bioavailability and physical perspectives. In particular, inadvertent changes to the polymorphic form that may affect drug product BA/BE can often be detected by drug product dissolution testing.
2. Influence on Manufacturing of the Drug Product:
Drug substance polymorphic forms can also exhibit different physical and mechanical properties, including hygroscopicity, particle shape, density, flowability, and compactibility, which in turn may affect processing of the drug substance and/or manufacturing of the drug product. Since an ANDA applicant should demonstrate that the generic drug product can be manufactured reliably using a validated process, we recommend that you pay close attention to polymorphism as it relates to pharmaceutical processing.
The effect of polymorphism on pharmaceutical processing also depends on the formulation and the manufacturing process. For a drug product manufactured by direct compression, the solid-state properties of the active ingredient will likely be critical to the manufacture of the drug product, particularly when it constitutes the bulk of the tablet mass. On the other hand, for a drug product manufactured by wet granulation, the solid-state properties of the active ingredient are often masked by the resultant granulation, and the solid-state properties of the active ingredient are less likely to affect the manufacture of the drug product. In the context of the effect of polymorphism on pharmaceutical processing, what is most relevant is the ability to consistently manufacture a drug product that conforms to applicable in-process controls and release specifications.
Polymorphic forms of the drug substance can undergo phase conversion when exposed to a range of manufacturing processes, such as drying, milling, micronization, wet granulation, spray-drying, and compaction. Exposure to environmental conditions such as humidity and temperature can also induce polymorph conversion. The extent of conversion generally depends on the relative stability of the polymorphs, kinetic barriers to phase conversion, and applied stress. Nonetheless, phase conversion generally is not of serious concern, provided that the conversion occurs consistently, as a part of a validated manufacturing process where critical manufacturing process variables are well understood and controlled, and when drug product BA/BE has been demonstrated.
3. Influence on Stability:
Polymorphs can have different physical and chemical (reactivity) properties. The most thermodynamically stable polymorphic form of a drug substance is often chosen during development based on the minimal potential for conversion to another polymorphic form and on its greater chemical stability. However, a metastable form can be chosen for various reasons, including bioavailability enhancement. Since an ANDA applicant must demonstrate that the generic drug product exhibits adequate stability, we recommend that you focus on the potential effect that a polymorphic form can have on drug product stability. Nonetheless, because drug product stability is affected by a multitude of other factors, including formulation, manufacturing process, and packaging, it is the stability of the drug product and not stability of the drug substance polymorphic form that should be the most relevant measure of drug quality.
Polymorphic screening:
The step one of the ICH guideline is the polymorphism screening. Since polymorphism is to be considered for each salt candidate, it is not possible to separate salt selection and polymorphism selection. Different solid phases can be stable in different environments. For example in case of enantiotropy, at temperature below the transition point, the low melting form is the thermodynamic stable form. A hydrate can crystallize from aqueous solution and an anhydrous phase from organic solutions, both forms being stable in the context of crystallization. An anhydrous phase can be stable at low relative humidity and a hydrate at high relative humidity. But 'metastable' or 'unstable' forms may coexist resulting from supersaturation or from desolvation or dehydration. All possibilities have to be explored in a polymorphism screening. In organic chemistry, metastable forms may survive years if a considerable activation energy barrier has to be overcome in moving from the metastable state to the stable state. This activation-energy barrier may be reduced by moisture, catalysts, impurities, excipients, temperature and the transformation into the stable form occurs spontaneously. Seeds of the stable form may accelerate transformations. In the last step of synthesis, the temperature is generally lowered during crystallization. At the beginning of the crystallization the metastable form which is more soluble, may crystallize first, depending on the metastable zone of crystallization. Through solvent mediated transition the metastable form should be transformed into the stable form. But depending of the crystal growth and of the solubility, this transformation may not happen and the metastable form remains in the solid phase. In the case of hydrates, the water activity of the solvent or of the atmosphere is the key parameter for hydrate formation. The formation of solvates and hydrates is often the source of metastable anhydrous forms obtained during drying. The number of solid phases which may be correlated with a drug substance can be very high if one considers that a drug substance may form several solvates with each solvent.
Many examples show that in early development metastable forms or amorphous solids are first obtained and that during the development the unexpected thermodynamic stable form appears emphasizes the relevance of the discovery of a new highly insoluble form in a liquid formulation. Transformation of the metastable form into the insoluble form. By increasing the temperature, the 'apparent solubility' of the metastable form decreases since the transformation into the stable form is accelerated by the increase of temperature. All polymorphic screening procedures consider crystallizations and parameters such as temperature, co-precipitation, slurry in different solvents and in different conditions in order to explore the parameters of manufacture. High throughput this new form growths slowly from a liquid formulation. The new form was very insoluble and it was necessary to develop a new formulation in which the new form could be dissolved in the concentration needed for the therapy. The solubility of both crystalline forms was measured in a great number of liquid systems at different temperatures. Figure 1b illustrates the observed behavior of the solubility results, due to kinetic systems are now considered at drug discovery stage [27–29]. Quenching from the melt, lyophilization, precipitation by adding a co-solvent allow us to obtain the amorphous state. Heating/cooling curves in DSC or by combined techniques permit to observe forms which are not obtained from solvents.
The strategy of the screening should permit to:
• Obtain the drug candidate as crystalline form
• Detect solvate formation
• Manufacture ‘unstable’ or ‘metastable’ forms
• Study hydrate formation by water sorption-desorption experiments (Hygroscopicity)
• Consider solvate formation by adding solvent atmosphere studies to the crystallizations
• Manufacture amorphous phase.
Friday, November 26, 2010
b
Polymorphic Pharmaceutical Compounds
Introduction:
The chemical industrial development in pharmaceutical industry is faced with the acceleration of the development time of new medicines and with harmonization guidelines which are required by health authorities for worldwide registration. Polymorphism is the ability of a substance to crystallize into different crystalline forms. These crystalline forms are called polymorphs or crystalline modifications. Polymorphs have the same liquid or gaseous state but they behave differently in the solid-state. The amorphous state is characterized by solidification in a disordered, random manner, structurally similar to the liquid-state. The expression pseudo-polymorphism applies to hydrates and solvates. These three types of solid phases are considered under the term ‘polymorphic behavior’ in this article. Review articles about polymorphism and relevance. Intrinsic properties of a new drug substance candidate are its pKa, its lipophilicity expressed by logP and its intrinsic chemical stability in solutions. Poor physical properties of substances may be changed by using the salt formation in case of acidic or basic compounds and by considering different polymorphs. Formulations are developed to improve solid-state properties and in certain cases affect the solid-state of the drug substance in the drug product. The ‘polymorphic’ behavior of organic substances is driven by thermodynamic and kinetic factors. Therefore several solid phases can coexist. Since the properties of the solid-state may be extremely relevant for the quality of drug products, the International Conference for Harmonization requires a polymorphic study of each new active ingredient with a three-step decision tree starting with detection of different solid phases, followed by the characterization of the different solid phases and if the properties are relevant for the drug product quantitative methods and specifications have to be developed for the drug substance and even for the drug product.
The most relevant property for health authorities is the bioavailability and the bioequivalence of formulation not always correlated with polymorphism, the stability and the robustness of the processes. The processing of the drug substances and drug products involve solvent, temperature and pressure changes as well as mechanical stress and different solid phases may coexist in the drug product. Organic substances show supersaturation behavior and unstable solid phases which should not exist in defined temperature, pressure and humidity may behave like stable forms. These solid metastable phases obtained outside their domains of stability will convert into the thermodynamic stable forms at given temperatures, pressures and relative humidities. These conversions driven by thermodynamic are governed by kinetic and are influenced by impurities, particle size, crystal defects, and presence of seeds. Design of the solid-state is the best choice of the salt candidate and the polymorphic form as early as possible in order to avoid delays due to new development, bioequivalence studies and upscale has to be taken into consideration since synthetic processes will be optimized from the first mg material to the production amount in tons range. For this challenging task, new technologies are now available: high throughput instrumentation, chemometrics, laboratory automation, in line or on line in process analytic have been added to the established high sophisticated technologies such as thermal analysis and calorimetry, X-ray diffraction, spectroscopy and combined techniques. On the other side, predictive computer tools are also available and the two approaches pushed academia and industry to apply better models and better tools in terms of precision and accuracy. Precise knowledge of thermodynamic stability and relationships between different solid phases is a pre-requisite for the manufacture of robust drug substance and drug products. It is also necessary to know the equilibration curves between the solid forms under the influence of the parameters humidity, temperature and pressure in order to predict changes for storage, stability, compatibility and pharmaceutical processes. The major hurdle for the pharmaceutical industry is to have to recall medicines because of polymorphism problems as it was the case for Ritonavir. Strategic development for both salt form and polymorphism are also reviewed. Adequate very sensitive quantification methods are needed for the development and are also now required for the monitoring of undesirable solid form(s).
Chemistry, manufacturing, and controls information must be submitted to support the approval of an abbreviated new drug application. This guidance is intended to assist applicants with the submission of ANDAs when a drug substance exists in polymorphic forms. Specifically, this guidance provides:
• FDA recommendations on assessing sameness when the drug substance exists in polymorphic forms.
Decision trees that provide recommendations on monitoring and controlling polymorphs and drug substances and/or drug products.
FDA’s guidance documents, including this guidance, do not establish legally enforceable responsibilities. Instead, guidances describe the Agency’s current thinking on a topic and should be viewed only as recommendations, unless specific regulatory or statutory requirements are cited. The use of the word should in Agency guidances means that something is suggested or recommended, but not required.
II. DEFINITION OF TERMS: POLYMORPHIC FORMS AND POLYMORPHISM
We recommend that ANDA applicants investigate whether the drug substance in question can exist in polymorphic forms. Polymorphic forms in the context of this guidance refer to crystalline and amorphous forms as well as solvate and hydrate forms, which are described below.
• Crystalline forms have different arrangements and/or conformations of the molecules in the crystal lattice.
• Amorphous forms consist of disordered arrangements of molecules that do not possess a distinguishable crystal lattice.
• Solvates are crystal forms containing either stoichiometric or nonstoichiometric amounts of a solvent. If the incorporated solvent is water, the solvate is commonly known as a hydrate.
When a drug substance exists in polymorphic forms, it is said to exhibit polymorphism.
III. GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF PHARMACEUTICAL SOLID POLYMORPHISM
A. Importance of Pharmaceutical Solid Polymorphism
Polymorphic forms of a drug substance can have different chemical and physical properties, including melting point, chemical reactivity, apparent solubility, dissolution rate, optical and mechanical properties, vapor pressure, and density. These properties can have a direct effect on the ability to process and/or manufacture the drug substance and the drug product, as well as on drug product stability, dissolution, and bioavailability. Thus, polymorphism can affect the quality, safety, and efficacy of the drug product.
B. Characterization of Polymorphs
There are a number of methods that can be used to characterize polymorphs of a drug substance.11 Demonstration of a nonequivalent structure by single crystal X-ray diffraction is currently regarded as the definitive evidence of polymorphism. X-ray powder diffraction can also be used to provide unequivocal proof of polymorphism. Other methods, including microscopy, thermal analysis, and spectroscopy are helpful to further characterize polymorphic forms.
C. Influence of Polymorphism on Drug Substance and Drug Product
1. Influence on Solubility, Dissolution, and Bioavailability (BA) and Bioequivalence (BE):
The solid-state properties of a drug substance can have a significant influence on the apparent solubility of the drug substance. Since polymorphic forms differ in their internal solid-state structure, a drug substance that exists in various polymorphic forms can have different aqueous solubilities and dissolution rates. When there are differences in the apparent solubilities of the various polymorphic forms, we recommend that you focus on the potential effect such differences can have on drug product bioavailability (BA) and bioequivalence (BE).
Whether drug product BA/BE can be affected by the differences in apparent solubilities of the various polymorphic forms depends on the various physiological factors that govern the rate and extent of drug absorption including gastrointestinal motility, drug dissolution, and intestinal permeability. In this context, the Biopharmaceutics Classification System provides a useful scientific framework for regulatory decisions regarding drug substance polymorphism.
For a drug whose absorption is only limited by its dissolution, large differences in the apparent solubilities of the various polymorphic forms are likely to affect BA/BE. On the other hand, for a drug whose absorption is only limited by its intestinal permeability, differences in the apparent solubilities of the various polymorphic forms are less likely to affect BA/BE. Furthermore, when the apparent solubilities of the polymorphic forms are sufficiently high and drug dissolution is rapid in relation to gastric emptying, differences in the solubilities of the polymorphic forms are unlikely to affect BA/BE.
Upon demonstration of in-vivo bioequivalence between the generic drug product and the reference listed drug, in-vitro dissolution testing is then used to assess the lot-to-lot quality of the generic drug product. Drug product dissolution testing frequently provides a suitable means to identify and control the quality of the product from both the bioavailability and physical perspectives. In particular, inadvertent changes to the polymorphic form that may affect drug product BA/BE can often be detected by drug product dissolution testing.
2. Influence on Manufacturing of the Drug Product:
Drug substance polymorphic forms can also exhibit different physical and mechanical properties, including hygroscopicity, particle shape, density, flowability, and compactibility, which in turn may affect processing of the drug substance and/or manufacturing of the drug product. Since an ANDA applicant should demonstrate that the generic drug product can be manufactured reliably using a validated process, we recommend that you pay close attention to polymorphism as it relates to pharmaceutical processing.
The effect of polymorphism on pharmaceutical processing also depends on the formulation and the manufacturing process. For a drug product manufactured by direct compression, the solid-state properties of the active ingredient will likely be critical to the manufacture of the drug product, particularly when it constitutes the bulk of the tablet mass. On the other hand, for a drug product manufactured by wet granulation, the solid-state properties of the active ingredient are often masked by the resultant granulation, and the solid-state properties of the active ingredient are less likely to affect the manufacture of the drug product. In the context of the effect of polymorphism on pharmaceutical processing, what is most relevant is the ability to consistently manufacture a drug product that conforms to applicable in-process controls and release specifications.
Polymorphic forms of the drug substance can undergo phase conversion when exposed to a range of manufacturing processes, such as drying, milling, micronization, wet granulation, spray-drying, and compaction. Exposure to environmental conditions such as humidity and temperature can also induce polymorph conversion. The extent of conversion generally depends on the relative stability of the polymorphs, kinetic barriers to phase conversion, and applied stress. Nonetheless, phase conversion generally is not of serious concern, provided that the conversion occurs consistently, as a part of a validated manufacturing process where critical manufacturing process variables are well understood and controlled, and when drug product BA/BE has been demonstrated.
3. Influence on Stability:
Polymorphs can have different physical and chemical (reactivity) properties. The most thermodynamically stable polymorphic form of a drug substance is often chosen during development based on the minimal potential for conversion to another polymorphic form and on its greater chemical stability. However, a metastable form can be chosen for various reasons, including bioavailability enhancement. Since an ANDA applicant must demonstrate that the generic drug product exhibits adequate stability, we recommend that you focus on the potential effect that a polymorphic form can have on drug product stability. Nonetheless, because drug product stability is affected by a multitude of other factors, including formulation, manufacturing process, and packaging, it is the stability of the drug product and not stability of the drug substance polymorphic form that should be the most relevant measure of drug quality.
Polymorphic screening:
The step one of the ICH guideline is the polymorphism screening. Since polymorphism is to be considered for each salt candidate, it is not possible to separate salt selection and polymorphism selection. Different solid phases can be stable in different environments. For example in case of enantiotropy, at temperature below the transition point, the low melting form is the thermodynamic stable form. A hydrate can crystallize from aqueous solution and an anhydrous phase from organic solutions, both forms being stable in the context of crystallization. An anhydrous phase can be stable at low relative humidity and a hydrate at high relative humidity. But 'metastable' or 'unstable' forms may coexist resulting from supersaturation or from desolvation or dehydration. All possibilities have to be explored in a polymorphism screening. In organic chemistry, metastable forms may survive years if a considerable activation energy barrier has to be overcome in moving from the metastable state to the stable state. This activation-energy barrier may be reduced by moisture, catalysts, impurities, excipients, temperature and the transformation into the stable form occurs spontaneously. Seeds of the stable form may accelerate transformations. In the last step of synthesis, the temperature is generally lowered during crystallization. At the beginning of the crystallization the metastable form which is more soluble, may crystallize first, depending on the metastable zone of crystallization. Through solvent mediated transition the metastable form should be transformed into the stable form. But depending of the crystal growth and of the solubility, this transformation may not happen and the metastable form remains in the solid phase. In the case of hydrates, the water activity of the solvent or of the atmosphere is the key parameter for hydrate formation. The formation of solvates and hydrates is often the source of metastable anhydrous forms obtained during drying. The number of solid phases which may be correlated with a drug substance can be very high if one considers that a drug substance may form several solvates with each solvent.
Many examples show that in early development metastable forms or amorphous solids are first obtained and that during the development the unexpected thermodynamic stable form appears emphasizes the relevance of the discovery of a new highly insoluble form in a liquid formulation. Transformation of the metastable form into the insoluble form. By increasing the temperature, the 'apparent solubility' of the metastable form decreases since the transformation into the stable form is accelerated by the increase of temperature. All polymorphic screening procedures consider crystallizations and parameters such as temperature, co-precipitation, slurry in different solvents and in different conditions in order to explore the parameters of manufacture. High throughput this new form growths slowly from a liquid formulation. The new form was very insoluble and it was necessary to develop a new formulation in which the new form could be dissolved in the concentration needed for the therapy. The solubility of both crystalline forms was measured in a great number of liquid systems at different temperatures. Figure 1b illustrates the observed behavior of the solubility results, due to kinetic systems are now considered at drug discovery stage [27–29]. Quenching from the melt, lyophilization, precipitation by adding a co-solvent allow us to obtain the amorphous state. Heating/cooling curves in DSC or by combined techniques permit to observe forms which are not obtained from solvents.
The strategy of the screening should permit to:
• Obtain the drug candidate as crystalline form
• Detect solvate formation
• Manufacture ‘unstable’ or ‘metastable’ forms
• Study hydrate formation by water sorption-desorption experiments (Hygroscopicity)
• Consider solvate formation by adding solvent atmosphere studies to the crystallizations
• Manufacture amorphous phase.
Introduction:
The chemical industrial development in pharmaceutical industry is faced with the acceleration of the development time of new medicines and with harmonization guidelines which are required by health authorities for worldwide registration. Polymorphism is the ability of a substance to crystallize into different crystalline forms. These crystalline forms are called polymorphs or crystalline modifications. Polymorphs have the same liquid or gaseous state but they behave differently in the solid-state. The amorphous state is characterized by solidification in a disordered, random manner, structurally similar to the liquid-state. The expression pseudo-polymorphism applies to hydrates and solvates. These three types of solid phases are considered under the term ‘polymorphic behavior’ in this article. Review articles about polymorphism and relevance. Intrinsic properties of a new drug substance candidate are its pKa, its lipophilicity expressed by logP and its intrinsic chemical stability in solutions. Poor physical properties of substances may be changed by using the salt formation in case of acidic or basic compounds and by considering different polymorphs. Formulations are developed to improve solid-state properties and in certain cases affect the solid-state of the drug substance in the drug product. The ‘polymorphic’ behavior of organic substances is driven by thermodynamic and kinetic factors. Therefore several solid phases can coexist. Since the properties of the solid-state may be extremely relevant for the quality of drug products, the International Conference for Harmonization requires a polymorphic study of each new active ingredient with a three-step decision tree starting with detection of different solid phases, followed by the characterization of the different solid phases and if the properties are relevant for the drug product quantitative methods and specifications have to be developed for the drug substance and even for the drug product.
The most relevant property for health authorities is the bioavailability and the bioequivalence of formulation not always correlated with polymorphism, the stability and the robustness of the processes. The processing of the drug substances and drug products involve solvent, temperature and pressure changes as well as mechanical stress and different solid phases may coexist in the drug product. Organic substances show supersaturation behavior and unstable solid phases which should not exist in defined temperature, pressure and humidity may behave like stable forms. These solid metastable phases obtained outside their domains of stability will convert into the thermodynamic stable forms at given temperatures, pressures and relative humidities. These conversions driven by thermodynamic are governed by kinetic and are influenced by impurities, particle size, crystal defects, and presence of seeds. Design of the solid-state is the best choice of the salt candidate and the polymorphic form as early as possible in order to avoid delays due to new development, bioequivalence studies and upscale has to be taken into consideration since synthetic processes will be optimized from the first mg material to the production amount in tons range. For this challenging task, new technologies are now available: high throughput instrumentation, chemometrics, laboratory automation, in line or on line in process analytic have been added to the established high sophisticated technologies such as thermal analysis and calorimetry, X-ray diffraction, spectroscopy and combined techniques. On the other side, predictive computer tools are also available and the two approaches pushed academia and industry to apply better models and better tools in terms of precision and accuracy. Precise knowledge of thermodynamic stability and relationships between different solid phases is a pre-requisite for the manufacture of robust drug substance and drug products. It is also necessary to know the equilibration curves between the solid forms under the influence of the parameters humidity, temperature and pressure in order to predict changes for storage, stability, compatibility and pharmaceutical processes. The major hurdle for the pharmaceutical industry is to have to recall medicines because of polymorphism problems as it was the case for Ritonavir. Strategic development for both salt form and polymorphism are also reviewed. Adequate very sensitive quantification methods are needed for the development and are also now required for the monitoring of undesirable solid form(s).
Chemistry, manufacturing, and controls information must be submitted to support the approval of an abbreviated new drug application. This guidance is intended to assist applicants with the submission of ANDAs when a drug substance exists in polymorphic forms. Specifically, this guidance provides:
• FDA recommendations on assessing sameness when the drug substance exists in polymorphic forms.
Decision trees that provide recommendations on monitoring and controlling polymorphs and drug substances and/or drug products.
FDA’s guidance documents, including this guidance, do not establish legally enforceable responsibilities. Instead, guidances describe the Agency’s current thinking on a topic and should be viewed only as recommendations, unless specific regulatory or statutory requirements are cited. The use of the word should in Agency guidances means that something is suggested or recommended, but not required.
II. DEFINITION OF TERMS: POLYMORPHIC FORMS AND POLYMORPHISM
We recommend that ANDA applicants investigate whether the drug substance in question can exist in polymorphic forms. Polymorphic forms in the context of this guidance refer to crystalline and amorphous forms as well as solvate and hydrate forms, which are described below.
• Crystalline forms have different arrangements and/or conformations of the molecules in the crystal lattice.
• Amorphous forms consist of disordered arrangements of molecules that do not possess a distinguishable crystal lattice.
• Solvates are crystal forms containing either stoichiometric or nonstoichiometric amounts of a solvent. If the incorporated solvent is water, the solvate is commonly known as a hydrate.
When a drug substance exists in polymorphic forms, it is said to exhibit polymorphism.
III. GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF PHARMACEUTICAL SOLID POLYMORPHISM
A. Importance of Pharmaceutical Solid Polymorphism
Polymorphic forms of a drug substance can have different chemical and physical properties, including melting point, chemical reactivity, apparent solubility, dissolution rate, optical and mechanical properties, vapor pressure, and density. These properties can have a direct effect on the ability to process and/or manufacture the drug substance and the drug product, as well as on drug product stability, dissolution, and bioavailability. Thus, polymorphism can affect the quality, safety, and efficacy of the drug product.
B. Characterization of Polymorphs
There are a number of methods that can be used to characterize polymorphs of a drug substance.11 Demonstration of a nonequivalent structure by single crystal X-ray diffraction is currently regarded as the definitive evidence of polymorphism. X-ray powder diffraction can also be used to provide unequivocal proof of polymorphism. Other methods, including microscopy, thermal analysis, and spectroscopy are helpful to further characterize polymorphic forms.
C. Influence of Polymorphism on Drug Substance and Drug Product
1. Influence on Solubility, Dissolution, and Bioavailability (BA) and Bioequivalence (BE):
The solid-state properties of a drug substance can have a significant influence on the apparent solubility of the drug substance. Since polymorphic forms differ in their internal solid-state structure, a drug substance that exists in various polymorphic forms can have different aqueous solubilities and dissolution rates. When there are differences in the apparent solubilities of the various polymorphic forms, we recommend that you focus on the potential effect such differences can have on drug product bioavailability (BA) and bioequivalence (BE).
Whether drug product BA/BE can be affected by the differences in apparent solubilities of the various polymorphic forms depends on the various physiological factors that govern the rate and extent of drug absorption including gastrointestinal motility, drug dissolution, and intestinal permeability. In this context, the Biopharmaceutics Classification System provides a useful scientific framework for regulatory decisions regarding drug substance polymorphism.
For a drug whose absorption is only limited by its dissolution, large differences in the apparent solubilities of the various polymorphic forms are likely to affect BA/BE. On the other hand, for a drug whose absorption is only limited by its intestinal permeability, differences in the apparent solubilities of the various polymorphic forms are less likely to affect BA/BE. Furthermore, when the apparent solubilities of the polymorphic forms are sufficiently high and drug dissolution is rapid in relation to gastric emptying, differences in the solubilities of the polymorphic forms are unlikely to affect BA/BE.
Upon demonstration of in-vivo bioequivalence between the generic drug product and the reference listed drug, in-vitro dissolution testing is then used to assess the lot-to-lot quality of the generic drug product. Drug product dissolution testing frequently provides a suitable means to identify and control the quality of the product from both the bioavailability and physical perspectives. In particular, inadvertent changes to the polymorphic form that may affect drug product BA/BE can often be detected by drug product dissolution testing.
2. Influence on Manufacturing of the Drug Product:
Drug substance polymorphic forms can also exhibit different physical and mechanical properties, including hygroscopicity, particle shape, density, flowability, and compactibility, which in turn may affect processing of the drug substance and/or manufacturing of the drug product. Since an ANDA applicant should demonstrate that the generic drug product can be manufactured reliably using a validated process, we recommend that you pay close attention to polymorphism as it relates to pharmaceutical processing.
The effect of polymorphism on pharmaceutical processing also depends on the formulation and the manufacturing process. For a drug product manufactured by direct compression, the solid-state properties of the active ingredient will likely be critical to the manufacture of the drug product, particularly when it constitutes the bulk of the tablet mass. On the other hand, for a drug product manufactured by wet granulation, the solid-state properties of the active ingredient are often masked by the resultant granulation, and the solid-state properties of the active ingredient are less likely to affect the manufacture of the drug product. In the context of the effect of polymorphism on pharmaceutical processing, what is most relevant is the ability to consistently manufacture a drug product that conforms to applicable in-process controls and release specifications.
Polymorphic forms of the drug substance can undergo phase conversion when exposed to a range of manufacturing processes, such as drying, milling, micronization, wet granulation, spray-drying, and compaction. Exposure to environmental conditions such as humidity and temperature can also induce polymorph conversion. The extent of conversion generally depends on the relative stability of the polymorphs, kinetic barriers to phase conversion, and applied stress. Nonetheless, phase conversion generally is not of serious concern, provided that the conversion occurs consistently, as a part of a validated manufacturing process where critical manufacturing process variables are well understood and controlled, and when drug product BA/BE has been demonstrated.
3. Influence on Stability:
Polymorphs can have different physical and chemical (reactivity) properties. The most thermodynamically stable polymorphic form of a drug substance is often chosen during development based on the minimal potential for conversion to another polymorphic form and on its greater chemical stability. However, a metastable form can be chosen for various reasons, including bioavailability enhancement. Since an ANDA applicant must demonstrate that the generic drug product exhibits adequate stability, we recommend that you focus on the potential effect that a polymorphic form can have on drug product stability. Nonetheless, because drug product stability is affected by a multitude of other factors, including formulation, manufacturing process, and packaging, it is the stability of the drug product and not stability of the drug substance polymorphic form that should be the most relevant measure of drug quality.
Polymorphic screening:
The step one of the ICH guideline is the polymorphism screening. Since polymorphism is to be considered for each salt candidate, it is not possible to separate salt selection and polymorphism selection. Different solid phases can be stable in different environments. For example in case of enantiotropy, at temperature below the transition point, the low melting form is the thermodynamic stable form. A hydrate can crystallize from aqueous solution and an anhydrous phase from organic solutions, both forms being stable in the context of crystallization. An anhydrous phase can be stable at low relative humidity and a hydrate at high relative humidity. But 'metastable' or 'unstable' forms may coexist resulting from supersaturation or from desolvation or dehydration. All possibilities have to be explored in a polymorphism screening. In organic chemistry, metastable forms may survive years if a considerable activation energy barrier has to be overcome in moving from the metastable state to the stable state. This activation-energy barrier may be reduced by moisture, catalysts, impurities, excipients, temperature and the transformation into the stable form occurs spontaneously. Seeds of the stable form may accelerate transformations. In the last step of synthesis, the temperature is generally lowered during crystallization. At the beginning of the crystallization the metastable form which is more soluble, may crystallize first, depending on the metastable zone of crystallization. Through solvent mediated transition the metastable form should be transformed into the stable form. But depending of the crystal growth and of the solubility, this transformation may not happen and the metastable form remains in the solid phase. In the case of hydrates, the water activity of the solvent or of the atmosphere is the key parameter for hydrate formation. The formation of solvates and hydrates is often the source of metastable anhydrous forms obtained during drying. The number of solid phases which may be correlated with a drug substance can be very high if one considers that a drug substance may form several solvates with each solvent.
Many examples show that in early development metastable forms or amorphous solids are first obtained and that during the development the unexpected thermodynamic stable form appears emphasizes the relevance of the discovery of a new highly insoluble form in a liquid formulation. Transformation of the metastable form into the insoluble form. By increasing the temperature, the 'apparent solubility' of the metastable form decreases since the transformation into the stable form is accelerated by the increase of temperature. All polymorphic screening procedures consider crystallizations and parameters such as temperature, co-precipitation, slurry in different solvents and in different conditions in order to explore the parameters of manufacture. High throughput this new form growths slowly from a liquid formulation. The new form was very insoluble and it was necessary to develop a new formulation in which the new form could be dissolved in the concentration needed for the therapy. The solubility of both crystalline forms was measured in a great number of liquid systems at different temperatures. Figure 1b illustrates the observed behavior of the solubility results, due to kinetic systems are now considered at drug discovery stage [27–29]. Quenching from the melt, lyophilization, precipitation by adding a co-solvent allow us to obtain the amorphous state. Heating/cooling curves in DSC or by combined techniques permit to observe forms which are not obtained from solvents.
The strategy of the screening should permit to:
• Obtain the drug candidate as crystalline form
• Detect solvate formation
• Manufacture ‘unstable’ or ‘metastable’ forms
• Study hydrate formation by water sorption-desorption experiments (Hygroscopicity)
• Consider solvate formation by adding solvent atmosphere studies to the crystallizations
• Manufacture amorphous phase.
b
Phytophthora cinnamomi
IDENTITY
Name of plant: Phytophthora cinnamomi Rands
Taxonomic position: Fungi: Oomycetes: Peronosporales
Common names: In English it has Root and fruit rot of avocado,
In French it has Pourriture des racines, pourriture du collet,
In German it has Phytophthora Wurzel und Stammfäule,
In Spanish it has Podredumbre de la raíz.
Bayer computer code: PHYTCN
EU Annex designation: II/B
HOSTS:
The host range is very wide; Phytophthora cinnamomi is the most widely distributed Phytophthora species, with nearly thousand of host species in Zentmyer, 1983. The principal food crop hosts are avocados in Persea Americana, and pineapples, it causes root and heart rot. Phytophthora cinnamomi also attacks Cinnamomum, Castanea, Coniferales, Fagus, Eucalyptus, and Juglans, Quercus and many shrubs and ornamental trees. Its recorded host range includes most of the temperate fruit trees, but these are not important hosts in practice. In the EPPO region, avocados are a significant host, in the limited areas where they are grown [Allen, R.N., 1980].
GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION:
The geographical origin of Phytophthora cinnamomi is not clearly established. It was first described in Indonesia. Zentmyer suggests that the species is indigenous in Southeast Asia and in southern Africa, and spread across the Pacific to Latin America in the 18th Century. There is, however, no very clear evidence how such spread occurred. The appearance of the fungus in the EPPO region is much more recent. There is no useful purpose in giving a geographical distribution for countries where Phytophthora cinnamomi has been recorded on avocado, since the fungus is soil-borne, not host-specialized and can freely move from one crop to another. Phytophthora cinnamomi certainly already occurs on avocado in several Mediterranean countries [Baum, D., 1988].
EPPO region: France, Greece, Belgium, Ireland, Germany, Israel, Switzerland, Italy, Netherlands, Morocco, Russia, Portugal, Spain, Turkey, UK, Yugoslavia.
Asia: China, Philippines, India, Israel, Taiwan, Malaysia, Turkey, Japan, Viet Nam, Indonesia.
Africa: Burundi, Côte d'Ivoire, Madagascar, Guinea, Zimbabwe Cameroon, Réunion, Congo, Kenya, Gabon, Morocco, Rwanda, South Africa, Zaire, Uganda, Zambia.
North America: Canada, Mexico, USA.
Central America and Caribbean: Belize, Barbados, Costa Rica, Honduras, Dominica, Cuba, Dominican Republic, Guadeloupe, El Salvador, Haiti, Guatemala, Jamaica, Tobago, Martinique, Puerto Rico, St. Lucia, Trinidad, St. Vincent and Grenadines, and Panama.
South America: Argentina, Brazil, Bolivia, Colombia, Chile, Guyana, Ecuador, Venezuela, Peru.
Oceania: Fiji, Cook Islands, Micronesia, Papua New Guinea, Australia, and New Zealand [Coffey, M.D., 1987].
EU: Present.
Distribution map: See IMI
BIOLOGY:
Sporangia release motile zoospores into soil water, and these swim to small roots, encyst and germinate on the root surface. Penetration occurs within 24 h of germination. The fungus then spreads in the young feeder roots causing a rot which may extend into the base of the stem. Propagules may also be splashed onto and infect aerial parts of the plant. Temperature, moisture and pH all influence growth and reproduction of the fungus. Effects of these factors have been reviewed by Weste [Chaube, H.S., 1992].
Phytophthora cinnamomi survives in dead plant material and can survive for long periods in this substrate. This saprophytic phase can allow an increase in the population of the pathogen. Phytophthora cinnamomi may also survive in the soil as sporangia, mycelium, zoospore cysts, chlamydospores and oospores and survival can be extended in the presence of an organic substrate. Mycelium of Phytophthora cinnamomi can survive for at least 6 years in moist soil. Zoospore cysts can survive for at least 6 weeks at between -5 and -15 bar soil matric potential. Phytophthora cinnamomi is heterothallic; oospores are very rare, and are slow to germinate. Varying germination periods may help to maintain a low but continuing population. Chlamydospore survival is also influenced by soil matric potential, and chlamydospores can survive for at least 6 years if soil moisture exceeds 3% [Coit, J.E., 1988].
Chlamydospores form in soil, gravel or plant tissue during dry periods, germinate under favorable conditions and grow to form mycelia and sporangia or more chlamydospores. The latter may, in turn, remain dormant until conditions become suitable, then germinate to produce infective mycelia, sporangia and zoospores, or more chlamydospores. This cycle may continue for at least 5 years, provided there is a nutrient source and a non-competitive soil microflora [Kotzé, J.M., 1983].
Although Phytophthora cinnamomi was originally mainly reported in tropical and subtropical countries, it can apparently survive and develop in cooler countries, and does not seem to be obviously restricted by growing season or winter temperatures [MacDonald, J.D., 1988].
DETECTION AND IDENTIFICATION:
Symptoms
Phytophthora cinnamomi causes a rot of fine feeder roots, leading to dieback and death of host plants. Larger roots are only occasionally attacked. Other symptoms include wilt, stem cankers, and decline in yield, decreased fruit size, gum exudation, collar rot [Pegg, K.G., 1987].
Morphology
Hyphae with frequent nodules, up to 8 μm thick, hyphal swellings in clusters, typically spherical, average 42 μm diameter. Sporangiophores thin, proliferating through the empty sporangium or occasionally branched. Sporangia broadly ellipsoid to ovoid, 57 x 33 μm, no papilla, and slight apical thickening, not shed. Oogonia average 40 μm diameter, wall smooth, becoming yellowish with age. Antheridia amphigynous, 21-23 x 17 μm. A full description is given in Waterhouse & Waterston [Shea, S.R., 1980].
MEANS OF MOVEMENT AND DISPERSAL
On a local scale, the pathogen can be moved naturally by soil-splash, by wind-blown soil or debris, or by water movement and run-off in drainage or irrigation ditches. The most likely means of more distant movement is in contaminated soil or plant debris. Propagules can also be carried on machinery used for cultivation or harvesting and on seed. Movement of contaminated road gravel has resulted in initiation of new epidemics in Australia. Movement of contaminated soil with container-grown ornamentals can spread the pathogen to disease-free areas, and this is the most probable pathway for international spread. Avocado planting material should not normally carry the disease, but rootstock plants could do so, if these are traded as such [Smith, P.M., 1988].
PEST SIGNIFICANCE
Economic impact
The most significant food crop losses due to Phytophthora cinnamomi root rot occur in avocado, particularly in California, USA, Australia and South Africa. The disease on avocado has recently been reviewed by Coffey. Severe epidemics of Phytophthora cinnamomi have caused extensive damage to Eucalyptus forests in Australia. In temperate areas, Phytophthora cinnamomi causes serious damage to high value ornamental trees and shrubs produced by the nursery stock industry. It is also reported to infect trees in amenity plantings, forests or orchards, but there is little or no quantitative record of this, which suggests that losses are only minor [Pegg, K.G., 1992].
Control
Cultural control measures include alleviation of high soil moisture levels and improving aeration by increasing drainage, and attention to mineral nutrition. Elements of the soil microflora suppress Phytophthora cinnamomi in some soils and may be potential biocontrol agents. These factors were reviewed by Weste in 1983. Soil solarization also controls Phytophthora cinnamomi on young avocado plants. Smith reviewed the combination of measures for controlling the disease in nurseries. An integrated approach is generally taken to control Phytophthora cinnamomi on avocado [Toerien, J.C., 1989].
Chemical control is possible with systemic fungicides, particularly fosetyl aluminium and metalaxyl applied by soil drench, foliar spray or trunk injection. Addition of elemental sulfur reduced disease incidence in pineapple, apparently through effects on soil pH. Some rootstocks of avocado show tolerance, and much work is reported on testing for resistance in avocado [Smith, P.M., 1989].
Phytosanitary risk
The pathogen is already present in much of the EPPO region, and it is not clear that there are any whole countries or large areas within countries where Phytophthora cinnamomi is known not to occur. As for other Phytophthora spp. on woody plants, low levels of infestation may be difficult to recognize. Phytophthora cinnamomi has not been listed as a quarantine pest by EPPO or by any other regional plant protection organization. In a recent survey of possible new quarantine pests for the EPPO region, it was rated as doubtful. Avocado growers should certainly seek to exclude Phytophthora cinnamomi or keep populations down to low levels, by operating strict hygienic measures. However, it is not clear that imported material requires special measures, different from those taken domestically [Zentmyer, G.A., 1988].
PHYTOSANITARY MEASURES
Hygienic precautions can be applied to exclude Phytophthora cinnamomi from a place of production. Unsterilized soil or growing medium, or farm machinery, should not be brought in. Introduced plants should be kept apart until their phytosanitary status has been checked. All propagation should be done from healthy plants or seed. Cultural measures should be taken to reduce the risk of spread in case of introduction. If land does become infested, incidence of Phytophthora cinnamomi can be reduced, if not necessarily eliminated, by leaving the land under non-susceptible crops for at least 4 years, and by applying various control measures. In 1988 Baum & Pinkas report on the first appearance of Phytophthora cinnamomi on avocado in Israel, and on the attempt to eradicate the disease, which was not successful [MacDonald, J.D., 1988].
REFERENCES:
1. Allen, R.N., Fungicidal control in pineapple and avocado of diseases caused by Phytophthora cinnamomi, 1980.
2. Baum, D., Phytophthora root, 1988.
3. Coffey, M.D., Phytophthora root rot of avocado, Coffey, 1987.
4. Chaube, H.S., Phytophthora root rot of avocado, 1992.
5. Coit, J.E., Pests and diseases of the avocado, 1988.
6. Kotzé, J.M., Integrated control of avocado root rot, 1983.
7. MacDonald, J.D., Influence of the matric and osmotic components of water potential on zoospore discharge in Phytophthora, 1988.
8. Pegg, K.G., Soil application of elemental sulphur as a control of Phytophthora cinnamomi root and heart rot of pineapple, 1987.
9. Shea, S.R., Seasonal variation in population levels of Phytophthora cinnamomi Rands, 1980.
10. Smith, P.M., Phytophthora cinnamomi, 1988.
11. Smith, P.M., Pests and diseases of hardy nursery stock, bedding plants and turf, 1989.
12. Pegg, K.G., Evaluation of the biological control potential of bacteria isolated from a soil suppressive to Phytophthora cinnamomi, 1992.
13. Toerien, J.C., Seasonal incidence of ring-neck on avocados and possible causes, 1989.
14. Zentmyer, G.A., Origin and distribution of four species of Phytophthora, 1988.
IDENTITY
Name of plant: Phytophthora cinnamomi Rands
Taxonomic position: Fungi: Oomycetes: Peronosporales
Common names: In English it has Root and fruit rot of avocado,
In French it has Pourriture des racines, pourriture du collet,
In German it has Phytophthora Wurzel und Stammfäule,
In Spanish it has Podredumbre de la raíz.
Bayer computer code: PHYTCN
EU Annex designation: II/B
HOSTS:
The host range is very wide; Phytophthora cinnamomi is the most widely distributed Phytophthora species, with nearly thousand of host species in Zentmyer, 1983. The principal food crop hosts are avocados in Persea Americana, and pineapples, it causes root and heart rot. Phytophthora cinnamomi also attacks Cinnamomum, Castanea, Coniferales, Fagus, Eucalyptus, and Juglans, Quercus and many shrubs and ornamental trees. Its recorded host range includes most of the temperate fruit trees, but these are not important hosts in practice. In the EPPO region, avocados are a significant host, in the limited areas where they are grown [Allen, R.N., 1980].
GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION:
The geographical origin of Phytophthora cinnamomi is not clearly established. It was first described in Indonesia. Zentmyer suggests that the species is indigenous in Southeast Asia and in southern Africa, and spread across the Pacific to Latin America in the 18th Century. There is, however, no very clear evidence how such spread occurred. The appearance of the fungus in the EPPO region is much more recent. There is no useful purpose in giving a geographical distribution for countries where Phytophthora cinnamomi has been recorded on avocado, since the fungus is soil-borne, not host-specialized and can freely move from one crop to another. Phytophthora cinnamomi certainly already occurs on avocado in several Mediterranean countries [Baum, D., 1988].
EPPO region: France, Greece, Belgium, Ireland, Germany, Israel, Switzerland, Italy, Netherlands, Morocco, Russia, Portugal, Spain, Turkey, UK, Yugoslavia.
Asia: China, Philippines, India, Israel, Taiwan, Malaysia, Turkey, Japan, Viet Nam, Indonesia.
Africa: Burundi, Côte d'Ivoire, Madagascar, Guinea, Zimbabwe Cameroon, Réunion, Congo, Kenya, Gabon, Morocco, Rwanda, South Africa, Zaire, Uganda, Zambia.
North America: Canada, Mexico, USA.
Central America and Caribbean: Belize, Barbados, Costa Rica, Honduras, Dominica, Cuba, Dominican Republic, Guadeloupe, El Salvador, Haiti, Guatemala, Jamaica, Tobago, Martinique, Puerto Rico, St. Lucia, Trinidad, St. Vincent and Grenadines, and Panama.
South America: Argentina, Brazil, Bolivia, Colombia, Chile, Guyana, Ecuador, Venezuela, Peru.
Oceania: Fiji, Cook Islands, Micronesia, Papua New Guinea, Australia, and New Zealand [Coffey, M.D., 1987].
EU: Present.
Distribution map: See IMI
BIOLOGY:
Sporangia release motile zoospores into soil water, and these swim to small roots, encyst and germinate on the root surface. Penetration occurs within 24 h of germination. The fungus then spreads in the young feeder roots causing a rot which may extend into the base of the stem. Propagules may also be splashed onto and infect aerial parts of the plant. Temperature, moisture and pH all influence growth and reproduction of the fungus. Effects of these factors have been reviewed by Weste [Chaube, H.S., 1992].
Phytophthora cinnamomi survives in dead plant material and can survive for long periods in this substrate. This saprophytic phase can allow an increase in the population of the pathogen. Phytophthora cinnamomi may also survive in the soil as sporangia, mycelium, zoospore cysts, chlamydospores and oospores and survival can be extended in the presence of an organic substrate. Mycelium of Phytophthora cinnamomi can survive for at least 6 years in moist soil. Zoospore cysts can survive for at least 6 weeks at between -5 and -15 bar soil matric potential. Phytophthora cinnamomi is heterothallic; oospores are very rare, and are slow to germinate. Varying germination periods may help to maintain a low but continuing population. Chlamydospore survival is also influenced by soil matric potential, and chlamydospores can survive for at least 6 years if soil moisture exceeds 3% [Coit, J.E., 1988].
Chlamydospores form in soil, gravel or plant tissue during dry periods, germinate under favorable conditions and grow to form mycelia and sporangia or more chlamydospores. The latter may, in turn, remain dormant until conditions become suitable, then germinate to produce infective mycelia, sporangia and zoospores, or more chlamydospores. This cycle may continue for at least 5 years, provided there is a nutrient source and a non-competitive soil microflora [Kotzé, J.M., 1983].
Although Phytophthora cinnamomi was originally mainly reported in tropical and subtropical countries, it can apparently survive and develop in cooler countries, and does not seem to be obviously restricted by growing season or winter temperatures [MacDonald, J.D., 1988].
DETECTION AND IDENTIFICATION:
Symptoms
Phytophthora cinnamomi causes a rot of fine feeder roots, leading to dieback and death of host plants. Larger roots are only occasionally attacked. Other symptoms include wilt, stem cankers, and decline in yield, decreased fruit size, gum exudation, collar rot [Pegg, K.G., 1987].
Morphology
Hyphae with frequent nodules, up to 8 μm thick, hyphal swellings in clusters, typically spherical, average 42 μm diameter. Sporangiophores thin, proliferating through the empty sporangium or occasionally branched. Sporangia broadly ellipsoid to ovoid, 57 x 33 μm, no papilla, and slight apical thickening, not shed. Oogonia average 40 μm diameter, wall smooth, becoming yellowish with age. Antheridia amphigynous, 21-23 x 17 μm. A full description is given in Waterhouse & Waterston [Shea, S.R., 1980].
MEANS OF MOVEMENT AND DISPERSAL
On a local scale, the pathogen can be moved naturally by soil-splash, by wind-blown soil or debris, or by water movement and run-off in drainage or irrigation ditches. The most likely means of more distant movement is in contaminated soil or plant debris. Propagules can also be carried on machinery used for cultivation or harvesting and on seed. Movement of contaminated road gravel has resulted in initiation of new epidemics in Australia. Movement of contaminated soil with container-grown ornamentals can spread the pathogen to disease-free areas, and this is the most probable pathway for international spread. Avocado planting material should not normally carry the disease, but rootstock plants could do so, if these are traded as such [Smith, P.M., 1988].
PEST SIGNIFICANCE
Economic impact
The most significant food crop losses due to Phytophthora cinnamomi root rot occur in avocado, particularly in California, USA, Australia and South Africa. The disease on avocado has recently been reviewed by Coffey. Severe epidemics of Phytophthora cinnamomi have caused extensive damage to Eucalyptus forests in Australia. In temperate areas, Phytophthora cinnamomi causes serious damage to high value ornamental trees and shrubs produced by the nursery stock industry. It is also reported to infect trees in amenity plantings, forests or orchards, but there is little or no quantitative record of this, which suggests that losses are only minor [Pegg, K.G., 1992].
Control
Cultural control measures include alleviation of high soil moisture levels and improving aeration by increasing drainage, and attention to mineral nutrition. Elements of the soil microflora suppress Phytophthora cinnamomi in some soils and may be potential biocontrol agents. These factors were reviewed by Weste in 1983. Soil solarization also controls Phytophthora cinnamomi on young avocado plants. Smith reviewed the combination of measures for controlling the disease in nurseries. An integrated approach is generally taken to control Phytophthora cinnamomi on avocado [Toerien, J.C., 1989].
Chemical control is possible with systemic fungicides, particularly fosetyl aluminium and metalaxyl applied by soil drench, foliar spray or trunk injection. Addition of elemental sulfur reduced disease incidence in pineapple, apparently through effects on soil pH. Some rootstocks of avocado show tolerance, and much work is reported on testing for resistance in avocado [Smith, P.M., 1989].
Phytosanitary risk
The pathogen is already present in much of the EPPO region, and it is not clear that there are any whole countries or large areas within countries where Phytophthora cinnamomi is known not to occur. As for other Phytophthora spp. on woody plants, low levels of infestation may be difficult to recognize. Phytophthora cinnamomi has not been listed as a quarantine pest by EPPO or by any other regional plant protection organization. In a recent survey of possible new quarantine pests for the EPPO region, it was rated as doubtful. Avocado growers should certainly seek to exclude Phytophthora cinnamomi or keep populations down to low levels, by operating strict hygienic measures. However, it is not clear that imported material requires special measures, different from those taken domestically [Zentmyer, G.A., 1988].
PHYTOSANITARY MEASURES
Hygienic precautions can be applied to exclude Phytophthora cinnamomi from a place of production. Unsterilized soil or growing medium, or farm machinery, should not be brought in. Introduced plants should be kept apart until their phytosanitary status has been checked. All propagation should be done from healthy plants or seed. Cultural measures should be taken to reduce the risk of spread in case of introduction. If land does become infested, incidence of Phytophthora cinnamomi can be reduced, if not necessarily eliminated, by leaving the land under non-susceptible crops for at least 4 years, and by applying various control measures. In 1988 Baum & Pinkas report on the first appearance of Phytophthora cinnamomi on avocado in Israel, and on the attempt to eradicate the disease, which was not successful [MacDonald, J.D., 1988].
REFERENCES:
1. Allen, R.N., Fungicidal control in pineapple and avocado of diseases caused by Phytophthora cinnamomi, 1980.
2. Baum, D., Phytophthora root, 1988.
3. Coffey, M.D., Phytophthora root rot of avocado, Coffey, 1987.
4. Chaube, H.S., Phytophthora root rot of avocado, 1992.
5. Coit, J.E., Pests and diseases of the avocado, 1988.
6. Kotzé, J.M., Integrated control of avocado root rot, 1983.
7. MacDonald, J.D., Influence of the matric and osmotic components of water potential on zoospore discharge in Phytophthora, 1988.
8. Pegg, K.G., Soil application of elemental sulphur as a control of Phytophthora cinnamomi root and heart rot of pineapple, 1987.
9. Shea, S.R., Seasonal variation in population levels of Phytophthora cinnamomi Rands, 1980.
10. Smith, P.M., Phytophthora cinnamomi, 1988.
11. Smith, P.M., Pests and diseases of hardy nursery stock, bedding plants and turf, 1989.
12. Pegg, K.G., Evaluation of the biological control potential of bacteria isolated from a soil suppressive to Phytophthora cinnamomi, 1992.
13. Toerien, J.C., Seasonal incidence of ring-neck on avocados and possible causes, 1989.
14. Zentmyer, G.A., Origin and distribution of four species of Phytophthora, 1988.
b
Phytophthora cinnamomi
IDENTITY
Name of plant: Phytophthora cinnamomi Rands
Taxonomic position: Fungi: Oomycetes: Peronosporales
Common names: In English it has Root and fruit rot of avocado,
In French it has Pourriture des racines, pourriture du collet,
In German it has Phytophthora Wurzel und Stammfäule,
In Spanish it has Podredumbre de la raíz.
Bayer computer code: PHYTCN
EU Annex designation: II/B
HOSTS:
The host range is very wide; Phytophthora cinnamomi is the most widely distributed Phytophthora species, with nearly thousand of host species in Zentmyer, 1983. The principal food crop hosts are avocados in Persea Americana, and pineapples, it causes root and heart rot. Phytophthora cinnamomi also attacks Cinnamomum, Castanea, Coniferales, Fagus, Eucalyptus, and Juglans, Quercus and many shrubs and ornamental trees. Its recorded host range includes most of the temperate fruit trees, but these are not important hosts in practice. In the EPPO region, avocados are a significant host, in the limited areas where they are grown.
GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION:
The geographical origin of Phytophthora cinnamomi is not clearly established. It was first described in Indonesia. Zentmyer suggests that the species is indigenous in Southeast Asia and in southern Africa, and spread across the Pacific to Latin America in the 18th Century. There is, however, no very clear evidence how such spread occurred. The appearance of the fungus in the EPPO region is much more recent. There is no useful purpose in giving a geographical distribution for countries where Phytophthora cinnamomi has been recorded on avocado, since the fungus is soil-borne, not host-specialized and can freely move from one crop to another. Phytophthora cinnamomi certainly already occurs on avocado in several Mediterranean countries.
EPPO region: France, Greece, Belgium, Ireland, Germany, Israel, Switzerland, Italy, Netherlands, Morocco, Russia, Portugal, Spain, Turkey, UK, Yugoslavia.
Asia: China, Philippines, India, Israel, Taiwan, Malaysia, Turkey, Japan, Viet Nam, Indonesia.
Africa: Burundi, Côte d'Ivoire, Madagascar, Guinea, Zimbabwe Cameroon, Réunion, Congo, Kenya, Gabon, Morocco, Rwanda, South Africa, Zaire, Uganda, Zambia.
North America: Canada, Mexico, USA.
Central America and Caribbean: Belize, Barbados, Costa Rica, Honduras, Dominica, Cuba, Dominican Republic, Guadeloupe, El Salvador, Haiti, Guatemala, Jamaica, Tobago, Martinique, Puerto Rico, St. Lucia, Trinidad, St. Vincent and Grenadines, and Panama.
South America: Argentina, Brazil, Bolivia, Colombia, Chile, Guyana, Ecuador, Venezuela, Peru.
Oceania: Fiji, Cook Islands, Micronesia, Papua New Guinea, Australia, and New Zealand.
EU: Present.
Distribution map: See IMI
BIOLOGY:
Sporangia release motile zoospores into soil water, and these swim to small roots, encyst and germinate on the root surface. Penetration occurs within 24 h of germination. The fungus then spreads in the young feeder roots causing a rot which may extend into the base of the stem. Propagules may also be splashed onto and infect aerial parts of the plant. Temperature, moisture and pH all influence growth and reproduction of the fungus. Effects of these factors have been reviewed by Weste.
Phytophthora cinnamomi survives in dead plant material and can survive for long periods in this substrate. This saprophytic phase can allow an increase in the population of the pathogen. Phytophthora cinnamomi may also survive in the soil as sporangia, mycelium, zoospore cysts, chlamydospores and oospores and survival can be extended in the presence of an organic substrate. Mycelium of Phytophthora cinnamomi can survive for at least 6 years in moist soil. Zoospore cysts can survive for at least 6 weeks at between -5 and -15 bar soil matric potential. Phytophthora cinnamomi is heterothallic; oospores are very rare, and are slow to germinate. Varying germination periods may help to maintain a low but continuing population. Chlamydospore survival is also influenced by soil matric potential, and chlamydospores can survive for at least 6 years if soil moisture exceeds 3%.
Chlamydospores form in soil, gravel or plant tissue during dry periods, germinate under favorable conditions and grow to form mycelia and sporangia or more chlamydospores. The latter may, in turn, remain dormant until conditions become suitable, then germinate to produce infective mycelia, sporangia and zoospores, or more chlamydospores. This cycle may continue for at least 5 years, provided there is a nutrient source and a non-competitive soil microflora.
Although Phytophthora cinnamomi was originally mainly reported in tropical and subtropical countries, it can apparently survive and develop in cooler countries, and does not seem to be obviously restricted by growing season or winter temperatures.
DETECTION AND IDENTIFICATION:
Symptoms
Phytophthora cinnamomi causes a rot of fine feeder roots, leading to dieback and death of host plants. Larger roots are only occasionally attacked. Other symptoms include wilt, stem cankers, and decline in yield, decreased fruit size, gum exudation, collar rot.
Morphology
Hyphae with frequent nodules, up to 8 μm thick, hyphal swellings in clusters, typically spherical, average 42 μm diameter. Sporangiophores thin, proliferating through the empty sporangium or occasionally branched. Sporangia broadly ellipsoid to ovoid, 57 x 33 μm, no papilla, and slight apical thickening, not shed. Oogonia average 40 μm diameter, wall smooth, becoming yellowish with age. Antheridia amphigynous, 21-23 x 17 μm. A full description is given in Waterhouse & Waterston.
MEANS OF MOVEMENT AND DISPERSAL
On a local scale, the pathogen can be moved naturally by soil-splash, by wind-blown soil or debris, or by water movement and run-off in drainage or irrigation ditches. The most likely means of more distant movement is in contaminated soil or plant debris. Propagules can also be carried on machinery used for cultivation or harvesting and on seed. Movement of contaminated road gravel has resulted in initiation of new epidemics in Australia. Movement of contaminated soil with container-grown ornamentals can spread the pathogen to disease-free areas, and this is the most probable pathway for international spread. Avocado planting material should not normally carry the disease, but rootstock plants could do so, if these are traded as such.
PEST SIGNIFICANCE
Economic impact
The most significant food crop losses due to Phytophthora cinnamomi root rot occur in avocado, particularly in California, USA, Australia and South Africa. The disease on avocado has recently been reviewed by Coffey. Severe epidemics of Phytophthora cinnamomi have caused extensive damage to Eucalyptus forests in Australia. In temperate areas, Phytophthora cinnamomi causes serious damage to high value ornamental trees and shrubs produced by the nursery stock industry. It is also reported to infect trees in amenity plantings, forests or orchards, but there is little or no quantitative record of this, which suggests that losses are only minor.
Control
Cultural control measures include alleviation of high soil moisture levels and improving aeration by increasing drainage, and attention to mineral nutrition. Elements of the soil microflora suppress Phytophthora cinnamomi in some soils and may be potential biocontrol agents. These factors were reviewed by Weste in 1983. Soil solarization also controls Phytophthora cinnamomi on young avocado plants. Smith reviewed the combination of measures for controlling the disease in nurseries. An integrated approach is generally taken to control Phytophthora cinnamomi on avocado.
Chemical control is possible with systemic fungicides, particularly fosetyl aluminium and metalaxyl applied by soil drench, foliar spray or trunk injection. Addition of elemental sulfur reduced disease incidence in pineapple, apparently through effects on soil pH. Some rootstocks of avocado show tolerance, and much work is reported on testing for resistance in avocado.
Phytosanitary risk
The pathogen is already present in much of the EPPO region, and it is not clear that there are any whole countries or large areas within countries where Phytophthora cinnamomi is known not to occur. As for other Phytophthora spp. on woody plants, low levels of infestation may be difficult to recognize. Phytophthora cinnamomi has not been listed as a quarantine pest by EPPO or by any other regional plant protection organization. In a recent survey of possible new quarantine pests for the EPPO region, it was rated as doubtful. Avocado growers should certainly seek to exclude Phytophthora cinnamomi or keep populations down to low levels, by operating strict hygienic measures. However, it is not clear that imported material requires special measures, different from those taken domestically.
PHYTOSANITARY MEASURES
Hygienic precautions can be applied to exclude Phytophthora cinnamomi from a place of production. Unsterilized soil or growing medium, or farm machinery, should not be brought in. Introduced plants should be kept apart until their phytosanitary status has been checked. All propagation should be done from healthy plants or seed. Cultural measures should be taken to reduce the risk of spread in case of introduction. If land does become infested, incidence of Phytophthora cinnamomi can be reduced, if not necessarily eliminated, by leaving the land under non-susceptible crops for at least 4 years, and by applying various control measures. In 1988 Baum & Pinkas report on the first appearance of Phytophthora cinnamomi on avocado in Israel, and on the attempt to eradicate the disease, which was not successful.
REFERENCES:
1. Allen, R.N., Fungicidal control in pineapple and avocado of diseases caused by Phytophthora cinnamomi, 1980.
2. Baum, D., Phytophthora root, 1988.
3. Coffey, M.D., Phytophthora root rot of avocado, Coffey, 1987.
4. Chaube, H.S., Phytophthora root rot of avocado, 1992.
5. Coit, J.E., Pests and diseases of the avocado, 1988.
6. Kotzé, J.M., Integrated control of avocado root rot, 1983.
7. MacDonald, J.D., Influence of the matric and osmotic components of water potential on zoospore discharge in Phytophthora, 1988.
8. Pegg, K.G., Soil application of elemental sulphur as a control of Phytophthora cinnamomi root and heart rot of pineapple, 1987.
9. Shea, S.R., Seasonal variation in population levels of Phytophthora cinnamomi Rands, 1980.
10. Smith, P.M., Phytophthora cinnamomi, 1988.
11. Smith, P.M., Pests and diseases of hardy nursery stock, bedding plants and turf, 1989.
12. Pegg, K.G., Evaluation of the biological control potential of bacteria isolated from a soil suppressive to Phytophthora cinnamomi, 1992.
13. Toerien, J.C., Seasonal incidence of ring-neck on avocados and possible causes, 1989.
14. Zentmyer, G.A., Origin and distribution of four species of Phytophthora, 1988.
IDENTITY
Name of plant: Phytophthora cinnamomi Rands
Taxonomic position: Fungi: Oomycetes: Peronosporales
Common names: In English it has Root and fruit rot of avocado,
In French it has Pourriture des racines, pourriture du collet,
In German it has Phytophthora Wurzel und Stammfäule,
In Spanish it has Podredumbre de la raíz.
Bayer computer code: PHYTCN
EU Annex designation: II/B
HOSTS:
The host range is very wide; Phytophthora cinnamomi is the most widely distributed Phytophthora species, with nearly thousand of host species in Zentmyer, 1983. The principal food crop hosts are avocados in Persea Americana, and pineapples, it causes root and heart rot. Phytophthora cinnamomi also attacks Cinnamomum, Castanea, Coniferales, Fagus, Eucalyptus, and Juglans, Quercus and many shrubs and ornamental trees. Its recorded host range includes most of the temperate fruit trees, but these are not important hosts in practice. In the EPPO region, avocados are a significant host, in the limited areas where they are grown.
GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION:
The geographical origin of Phytophthora cinnamomi is not clearly established. It was first described in Indonesia. Zentmyer suggests that the species is indigenous in Southeast Asia and in southern Africa, and spread across the Pacific to Latin America in the 18th Century. There is, however, no very clear evidence how such spread occurred. The appearance of the fungus in the EPPO region is much more recent. There is no useful purpose in giving a geographical distribution for countries where Phytophthora cinnamomi has been recorded on avocado, since the fungus is soil-borne, not host-specialized and can freely move from one crop to another. Phytophthora cinnamomi certainly already occurs on avocado in several Mediterranean countries.
EPPO region: France, Greece, Belgium, Ireland, Germany, Israel, Switzerland, Italy, Netherlands, Morocco, Russia, Portugal, Spain, Turkey, UK, Yugoslavia.
Asia: China, Philippines, India, Israel, Taiwan, Malaysia, Turkey, Japan, Viet Nam, Indonesia.
Africa: Burundi, Côte d'Ivoire, Madagascar, Guinea, Zimbabwe Cameroon, Réunion, Congo, Kenya, Gabon, Morocco, Rwanda, South Africa, Zaire, Uganda, Zambia.
North America: Canada, Mexico, USA.
Central America and Caribbean: Belize, Barbados, Costa Rica, Honduras, Dominica, Cuba, Dominican Republic, Guadeloupe, El Salvador, Haiti, Guatemala, Jamaica, Tobago, Martinique, Puerto Rico, St. Lucia, Trinidad, St. Vincent and Grenadines, and Panama.
South America: Argentina, Brazil, Bolivia, Colombia, Chile, Guyana, Ecuador, Venezuela, Peru.
Oceania: Fiji, Cook Islands, Micronesia, Papua New Guinea, Australia, and New Zealand.
EU: Present.
Distribution map: See IMI
BIOLOGY:
Sporangia release motile zoospores into soil water, and these swim to small roots, encyst and germinate on the root surface. Penetration occurs within 24 h of germination. The fungus then spreads in the young feeder roots causing a rot which may extend into the base of the stem. Propagules may also be splashed onto and infect aerial parts of the plant. Temperature, moisture and pH all influence growth and reproduction of the fungus. Effects of these factors have been reviewed by Weste.
Phytophthora cinnamomi survives in dead plant material and can survive for long periods in this substrate. This saprophytic phase can allow an increase in the population of the pathogen. Phytophthora cinnamomi may also survive in the soil as sporangia, mycelium, zoospore cysts, chlamydospores and oospores and survival can be extended in the presence of an organic substrate. Mycelium of Phytophthora cinnamomi can survive for at least 6 years in moist soil. Zoospore cysts can survive for at least 6 weeks at between -5 and -15 bar soil matric potential. Phytophthora cinnamomi is heterothallic; oospores are very rare, and are slow to germinate. Varying germination periods may help to maintain a low but continuing population. Chlamydospore survival is also influenced by soil matric potential, and chlamydospores can survive for at least 6 years if soil moisture exceeds 3%.
Chlamydospores form in soil, gravel or plant tissue during dry periods, germinate under favorable conditions and grow to form mycelia and sporangia or more chlamydospores. The latter may, in turn, remain dormant until conditions become suitable, then germinate to produce infective mycelia, sporangia and zoospores, or more chlamydospores. This cycle may continue for at least 5 years, provided there is a nutrient source and a non-competitive soil microflora.
Although Phytophthora cinnamomi was originally mainly reported in tropical and subtropical countries, it can apparently survive and develop in cooler countries, and does not seem to be obviously restricted by growing season or winter temperatures.
DETECTION AND IDENTIFICATION:
Symptoms
Phytophthora cinnamomi causes a rot of fine feeder roots, leading to dieback and death of host plants. Larger roots are only occasionally attacked. Other symptoms include wilt, stem cankers, and decline in yield, decreased fruit size, gum exudation, collar rot.
Morphology
Hyphae with frequent nodules, up to 8 μm thick, hyphal swellings in clusters, typically spherical, average 42 μm diameter. Sporangiophores thin, proliferating through the empty sporangium or occasionally branched. Sporangia broadly ellipsoid to ovoid, 57 x 33 μm, no papilla, and slight apical thickening, not shed. Oogonia average 40 μm diameter, wall smooth, becoming yellowish with age. Antheridia amphigynous, 21-23 x 17 μm. A full description is given in Waterhouse & Waterston.
MEANS OF MOVEMENT AND DISPERSAL
On a local scale, the pathogen can be moved naturally by soil-splash, by wind-blown soil or debris, or by water movement and run-off in drainage or irrigation ditches. The most likely means of more distant movement is in contaminated soil or plant debris. Propagules can also be carried on machinery used for cultivation or harvesting and on seed. Movement of contaminated road gravel has resulted in initiation of new epidemics in Australia. Movement of contaminated soil with container-grown ornamentals can spread the pathogen to disease-free areas, and this is the most probable pathway for international spread. Avocado planting material should not normally carry the disease, but rootstock plants could do so, if these are traded as such.
PEST SIGNIFICANCE
Economic impact
The most significant food crop losses due to Phytophthora cinnamomi root rot occur in avocado, particularly in California, USA, Australia and South Africa. The disease on avocado has recently been reviewed by Coffey. Severe epidemics of Phytophthora cinnamomi have caused extensive damage to Eucalyptus forests in Australia. In temperate areas, Phytophthora cinnamomi causes serious damage to high value ornamental trees and shrubs produced by the nursery stock industry. It is also reported to infect trees in amenity plantings, forests or orchards, but there is little or no quantitative record of this, which suggests that losses are only minor.
Control
Cultural control measures include alleviation of high soil moisture levels and improving aeration by increasing drainage, and attention to mineral nutrition. Elements of the soil microflora suppress Phytophthora cinnamomi in some soils and may be potential biocontrol agents. These factors were reviewed by Weste in 1983. Soil solarization also controls Phytophthora cinnamomi on young avocado plants. Smith reviewed the combination of measures for controlling the disease in nurseries. An integrated approach is generally taken to control Phytophthora cinnamomi on avocado.
Chemical control is possible with systemic fungicides, particularly fosetyl aluminium and metalaxyl applied by soil drench, foliar spray or trunk injection. Addition of elemental sulfur reduced disease incidence in pineapple, apparently through effects on soil pH. Some rootstocks of avocado show tolerance, and much work is reported on testing for resistance in avocado.
Phytosanitary risk
The pathogen is already present in much of the EPPO region, and it is not clear that there are any whole countries or large areas within countries where Phytophthora cinnamomi is known not to occur. As for other Phytophthora spp. on woody plants, low levels of infestation may be difficult to recognize. Phytophthora cinnamomi has not been listed as a quarantine pest by EPPO or by any other regional plant protection organization. In a recent survey of possible new quarantine pests for the EPPO region, it was rated as doubtful. Avocado growers should certainly seek to exclude Phytophthora cinnamomi or keep populations down to low levels, by operating strict hygienic measures. However, it is not clear that imported material requires special measures, different from those taken domestically.
PHYTOSANITARY MEASURES
Hygienic precautions can be applied to exclude Phytophthora cinnamomi from a place of production. Unsterilized soil or growing medium, or farm machinery, should not be brought in. Introduced plants should be kept apart until their phytosanitary status has been checked. All propagation should be done from healthy plants or seed. Cultural measures should be taken to reduce the risk of spread in case of introduction. If land does become infested, incidence of Phytophthora cinnamomi can be reduced, if not necessarily eliminated, by leaving the land under non-susceptible crops for at least 4 years, and by applying various control measures. In 1988 Baum & Pinkas report on the first appearance of Phytophthora cinnamomi on avocado in Israel, and on the attempt to eradicate the disease, which was not successful.
REFERENCES:
1. Allen, R.N., Fungicidal control in pineapple and avocado of diseases caused by Phytophthora cinnamomi, 1980.
2. Baum, D., Phytophthora root, 1988.
3. Coffey, M.D., Phytophthora root rot of avocado, Coffey, 1987.
4. Chaube, H.S., Phytophthora root rot of avocado, 1992.
5. Coit, J.E., Pests and diseases of the avocado, 1988.
6. Kotzé, J.M., Integrated control of avocado root rot, 1983.
7. MacDonald, J.D., Influence of the matric and osmotic components of water potential on zoospore discharge in Phytophthora, 1988.
8. Pegg, K.G., Soil application of elemental sulphur as a control of Phytophthora cinnamomi root and heart rot of pineapple, 1987.
9. Shea, S.R., Seasonal variation in population levels of Phytophthora cinnamomi Rands, 1980.
10. Smith, P.M., Phytophthora cinnamomi, 1988.
11. Smith, P.M., Pests and diseases of hardy nursery stock, bedding plants and turf, 1989.
12. Pegg, K.G., Evaluation of the biological control potential of bacteria isolated from a soil suppressive to Phytophthora cinnamomi, 1992.
13. Toerien, J.C., Seasonal incidence of ring-neck on avocados and possible causes, 1989.
14. Zentmyer, G.A., Origin and distribution of four species of Phytophthora, 1988.
b
Phytophthora cinnamomi
IDENTITY
Name of plant: Phytophthora cinnamomi Rands
Taxonomic position: Fungi: Oomycetes: Peronosporales
Common names: In English it has Root and fruit rot of avocado,
In French it has Pourriture des racines, pourriture du collet,
In German it has Phytophthora Wurzel und Stammfäule,
In Spanish it has Podredumbre de la raíz.
Bayer computer code: PHYTCN
EU Annex designation: II/B
HOSTS:
The host range is very wide; Phytophthora cinnamomi is the most widely distributed Phytophthora species, with nearly thousand of host species in Zentmyer, 1983. The principal food crop hosts are avocados in Persea Americana, and pineapples, it causes root and heart rot. Phytophthora cinnamomi also attacks Castanea, Cinnamomum, Coniferales, Ericaceae Eucalyptus, Fagus, Juglans, Quercus and many ornamental trees and shrubs. Its recorded host range includes most of the temperate fruit trees, but these are not important hosts in practice. In the EPPO region, avocados are a significant host, in the limited areas where they are grown.
GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION:
The geographical origin of P. cinnamomi is not clearly established. It was first described in Indonesia. Zentmyer suggests that the species is indigenous in Southeast Asia and in southern Africa, and spread across the Pacific to Latin America in the 18th Century. There is, however, no very clear evidence how such spread occurred. The appearance of the fungus in the EPPO region is much more recent. There is no useful purpose in giving a geographical distribution for countries where Phytophthora cinnamomi has been recorded on avocado, since the fungus is soil-borne, not host-specialized and can freely move from one crop to another. P. cinnamomi certainly already occurs on avocado in several Mediterranean countries.
EPPO region: Belgium, France (including Corsica), Germany, Greece (except Crete), Ireland, Israel, Italy, Morocco, Netherlands, Portugal (including Azores), Russia (European), Spain (including Canary Islands), Switzerland, Turkey, UK (England), Yugoslavia.
Asia: China (Jiangsu), India (Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, West Bengal), Indonesia (Java, Sumatra), Israel, Japan (Honshu, Ryukyu Archipelago), Malaysia (Peninsular, Sabah), Philippines, Taiwan, Turkey, Viet Nam.
Africa: Burundi, Cameroon, Congo, Côte d'Ivoire, Gabon, Guinea, Kenya, Madagascar, Morocco, Réunion, Rwanda, South Africa, Uganda, Zaire, Zambia, Zimbabwe. 2 Phytophthora cinnamomi
North America: Canada, Mexico, USA (Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Mississippi, Missouri, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia).
Central America and Caribbean: Barbados, Belize, Costa Rica, Cuba, Dominica, Dominican Republic, El Salvador, Guadeloupe, Guatemala, Haiti, Honduras, Jamaica, Martinique, Panama, Puerto Rico, St. Lucia, St. Vincent and Grenadines, Trinidad and Tobago.
South America: Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, Guyana, Peru, Venezuela.
Oceania: Australia, Cook Islands, Fiji, Micronesia, New Zealand, Papua New Guinea.
EU: Present.
Distribution map: See IMI
BIOLOGY:
Sporangia release motile zoospores into soil water, and these swim to small roots, encyst and germinate on the root surface. Penetration occurs within 24 h of germination. The fungus then spreads in the young feeder roots causing a rot which may extend into the base of the stem. Propagules may also be splashed onto and infect aerial parts of the plant. Temperature, moisture and pH all influence growth and reproduction of the fungus. Effects of these factors have been reviewed by Weste.
P. cinnamomi survives in dead plant material (survival influenced by soil matric potential) and can survive for long periods in this substrate (Shea et al., 1980). This saprophytic phase can allow an increase in the population of the pathogen. P. cinnamomi may also survive in the soil as mycelium, sporangia, zoospore cysts, chlamydospores and oospores and survival can be extended in the presence of an organic substrate (Weste & Vithanage, 1979). Mycelium of P. cinnamomi can survive for at least 6 years in moist soil (Zentmyer & Mircetich, 1966). Zoospore cysts can survive for at least 6 weeks at between -5 and -15 bar soil matric potential (MacDonald & Duniway, 1978). P. cinnamomi is heterothallic; oospores are very rare, and are slow to germinate. Varying germination periods may help to maintain a low but continuing population. Chlamydospore survival is also influenced by soil matric potential, and chlamydospores can survive for at least 6 years if soil moisture exceeds 3% (Zentmyer & Mircetich, 1966).
Chlamydospores form in soil, gravel or plant tissue during dry periods, germinate under favourable (moist) conditions and grow to form mycelia and sporangia or more chlamydospores. The latter may, in turn, remain dormant until conditions become suitable, then germinate to produce infective mycelia, sporangia and zoospores, or more chlamydospores. This cycle may continue for at least 5 years, provided there is a nutrient source (organic matter) and a non-competitive soil microflora.
Although P. cinnamomi was originally mainly reported in tropical and subtropical countries, it can apparently survive and develop in cooler countries, and does not seem to be obviously restricted by growing season or winter temperatures. Phytophthora cinnamomi 3
DETECTION AND IDENTIFICATION:
Symptoms
Phytophthora cinnamomi causes a rot of fine feeder roots, leading to dieback and death of host plants. Larger roots are only occasionally attacked. Other symptoms include wilt, stem cankers, decline in yield, decreased fruit size, gum exudation, collar rot (if infected through grafts near soil level).
Morphology
Hyphae with frequent nodules, up to 8 μm thick, hyphal swellings in clusters, typically spherical, average 42 μm diameter. Sporangiophores thin (3 μm), proliferating through the empty sporangium or occasionally branched. Sporangia broadly ellipsoid to ovoid, 57 x 33 μm, no papilla, slight apical thickening, not shed. Oogonia average 40 μm diameter, wall smooth, becoming yellowish with age. Antheridia amphigynous, 21-23 x 17 μm. A full description is given in Waterhouse & Waterston.
MEANS OF MOVEMENT AND DISPERSAL
On a local scale, the pathogen can be moved naturally by soil-splash, by wind-blown soil or debris, or by water movement and run-off in drainage/irrigation ditches. The most likely means of more distant movement is in contaminated soil or plant debris. Propagules can also be carried on machinery used for cultivation or harvesting and on seed. Movement of contaminated road gravel has resulted in initiation of new epidemics in Australia (Weste, 1975). Movement of contaminated soil with container-grown ornamentals can spread the pathogen to disease-free areas, and this is the most probable pathway for international spread. Avocado planting material (scions, seeds) should not normally carry the disease, but rootstock plants could do so, if these are traded as such.
PEST SIGNIFICANCE
Economic impact
The most significant food crop losses due to P. cinnamomi root rot occur in avocado, particularly in California, USA (Coit, 1928), Australia (Allen et al., 1980) and South Africa (Toerien, 1979). The disease on avocado has recently been reviewed by Coffey (1992). Severe epidemics of P. cinnamomi have caused extensive damage to Eucalyptus forests in Australia (Weste & Taylor, 1971). In temperate areas, P. cinnamomi causes serious damage to high-value ornamental trees and shrubs produced by the nursery stock industry (Smith, 1988). It is also reported to infect trees in amenity plantings, forests or orchards, but there is little or no quantitative record of this, which suggests that losses are only minor.
Control
Cultural control measures include alleviation of high soil moisture levels and improving aeration by increasing drainage, and attention to mineral nutrition. Elements of the soil microflora suppress P. cinnamomi in some soils and may be potential biocontrol agents (Stirling et al., 1992). These factors were reviewed by Weste (1983). Soil solarization also controls P. cinnamomi on young avocado plants (Kotzé & Darvas, 1983). Smith et al. (1983) reviewed the combination of measures for controlling the disease in nurseries. An integrated approach is generally taken to control P. cinnamomi on avocado (Coffey, 1987).
Chemical control is possible with systemic fungicides, particularly fosetyl-aluminium (and phosphonic acid) and metalaxyl (e.g. Whiley et al., 1986), applied by soil drench, foliar spray or trunk injection. Addition of elemental sulfur reduced disease incidence in pineapple, apparently through effects on soil pH (Pegg, 1977). 4 Phytophthora cinnamomi
Some rootstocks of avocado show tolerance (Kotzé & Darvas, 1983), and much work is reported on testing for resistance in avocado.
Phytosanitary risk
The pathogen is already present in much of the EPPO region, and it is not clear that there are any whole countries or large areas within countries where P. cinnamomi is known not to occur. As for other Phytophthora spp. on woody plants, low levels of infestation may be difficult to recognize (Tsao, 1990). P. cinnamomi has not been listed as a quarantine pest by EPPO or by any other regional plant protection organization. In a recent survey of possible new quarantine pests for the EPPO region, it was rated as doubtful. Avocado growers should certainly seek to exclude P. cinnamomi or keep populations down to low levels, by operating strict hygienic measures. However, it is not clear that imported material requires special measures, different from those taken domestically.
PHYTOSANITARY MEASURES
Hygienic precautions can be applied to exclude P. cinnamomi from a place of production (Smith, 1988). Unsterilized soil or growing medium, or farm machinery, should not be brought in. Introduced plants should be kept apart until their phytosanitary status has been checked. All propagation should be done from healthy plants or seed. Cultural measures should be taken to reduce the risk of spread in case of introduction. If land does become infested, incidence of P. cinnamomi can be reduced, if not necessarily eliminated, by leaving the land under non-susceptible crops for at least 4 years, and by applying various control measures (see Pest significance). Baum & Pinkas (1988) report on the first appearance of P. cinnamomi on avocado in Israel, and on the attempt to eradicate the disease, which was not successful.
REFERENCES:
Allen, R.N.; Pegg, K.G.; Forsberg, L.I.; Firth, D.J. (1980) Fungicidal control in pineapple and avocado of diseases caused by Phytophthora cinnamomi. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture and Animal Husbandry 20, 119-124.
Baum, D.; Pinkas, Y. (1988) [Phytophthora root rot six years after its first appearance in Israel]. Hassadeh 69, 274-277.
Coffey, M.D. (1987) Phytophthora root rot of avocado: an integrated approach to control in California. Plant Disease 71, 1046-1052.
Coffey, M.D. (1992) Phytophthora root rot of avocado. In: Plant diseases of international importance. Volume III. Diseases of fruit crops (Ed. by Kumar, J.; Chaube, H.S.; Singh, U.S.; Mukhopadhyay, A.N)., pp. 423-444. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, USA.
Coit, J.E. (1928) Pests and diseases of the avocado. California Avocado Society Yearbook, pp. 18-21.
IMI (1991) Distribution Maps of Plant Diseases No. 302 (edition 6). CAB International, Wallingford, UK.
Kotzé, J.M.; Darvas, J.M. (1983) Integrated control of avocado root rot. California Agricultural Society Yearbook 67, 83-86.
MacDonald, J.D.; Duniway, J.M. (1978) Influence of the matric and osmotic components of water potential on zoospore discharge in Phytophthora. Phytopathology 68, 751-757.
Pegg, K.G. (1977) Soil application of elemental sulphur as a control of Phytophthora cinnamomi root and heart rot of pineapple. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture and Husbandry 17, 859-865.
Shea, S.R.; Gillen, K.J.; Leppard, W.I. (1980) Seasonal variation in population levels of Phytophthora cinnamomi Rands in soil in diseased, freely-drained Eucalyptus marginata Sm. sites in the northern jarrah forests of south-western Australia. Protection Ecology 2, 135-156. Phytophthora cinnamomi 5
Smith, P.M. (1988) Phytophthora cinnamomi. In: European handbook of plant diseases (Ed. by Smith, I.M.; Dunez, J.; Lelliott, R.A.; Phillips, D.H.; Archer, S.A.), pp. 213-215. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford, UK.
Smith, P.M.; Brooks, A.V.; Evans, E.J.; Halstead, A.J. (1983) Pests and diseases of hardy nursery stock, bedding plants and turf. In: Pest and disease handbook, 2nd edition (Ed. by Scopes, N.; Ledieu, M.), pp. 473-556. British Crop Protection Council, Croydon, UK.
Stirling, A.M.; Hayward, A.C.; Pegg, K.G. (1992) Evaluation of the biological control potential of bacteria isolated from a soil suppressive to Phytophthora cinnamomi. Australasian Plant Pathology 21, 133-142.
Toerien, J.C. (1979) Seasonal incidence of ring-neck on avocados and possible causes. South African Avocado Growers' Association Research Report 3, 49-51.
Tsao, P.H. (1990) Why many phytophthora root rots and crown rots of tree and horticultural crops remain undetected. Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 20, 11-18.
Waterhouse, G.M.; Waterston, J.M. (1966). Phytophthora cinnamomi. CMI Descriptions of Pathogenic Fungi and Bacteria No. 113. CAB International, Wallingford, UK.
Weste, G. (1975). The distribution of Phytophthora cinnamomi within the National Park, Wilsons Promontory, Victoria. Australian Journal of Botany 23, 67-76.
Weste, G. (1983) Population dynamics and survival of Phytophthora. In: Phytophthora, its biology, taxonomy, ecology and pathology (Ed. by Erwin, D.C.; Bartnicki-Garcia, S.; Tsao, P.H.), pp. 237-258. American Phytopathological Society, St. Paul, USA.
Weste, G.; Taylor, P. (1971) The invasion of native forest by Phytophthora cinnamomi 1. Brisbane Ranges, Victoria. Australian Journal of Botany 19, 281-294.
Weste, G.; Vithanage, K. (1979) Survival of chlamydospores of Phytophthora cinnamomi in several non-sterile, host-free forest soils and gravels at different soil water potentials. Australian Journal of Botany 27, 1-9.
Whiley, A.W.; Pegg, K.G.; Saranah, J.B.; Forsberg, L.I. (1986) The control of phytophthora root rot of avocado with fungicides and the effect of this disease on water relations, yield and ring neck. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 26, 249-253.
Zentmyer, G.A. (1961) Avocado diseases in the Americas. Ceiba 9, 61-79.
Zentmyer, G.A. (1983) The world of Phytophthora. In: Phytophthora, its biology, taxonomy, ecology and pathology (Ed. by Erwin, D.C.; Bartnicki-Garcia, S.; Tsao, P.H.), pp. 1-8. American Phytopathological Society, St. Paul, USA.
Zentmyer, G.A. (1988) Origin and distribution of four species of Phytophthora. Transactions of the British Mycological Society 91, 367-378.
Zentmyer, G.A.; Mircetich, S.M. (1966) Saprophytism and persistence in soil by Phytophthora cinnamomi. Phytopathology 56, 710-712.
IDENTITY
Name of plant: Phytophthora cinnamomi Rands
Taxonomic position: Fungi: Oomycetes: Peronosporales
Common names: In English it has Root and fruit rot of avocado,
In French it has Pourriture des racines, pourriture du collet,
In German it has Phytophthora Wurzel und Stammfäule,
In Spanish it has Podredumbre de la raíz.
Bayer computer code: PHYTCN
EU Annex designation: II/B
HOSTS:
The host range is very wide; Phytophthora cinnamomi is the most widely distributed Phytophthora species, with nearly thousand of host species in Zentmyer, 1983. The principal food crop hosts are avocados in Persea Americana, and pineapples, it causes root and heart rot. Phytophthora cinnamomi also attacks Castanea, Cinnamomum, Coniferales, Ericaceae Eucalyptus, Fagus, Juglans, Quercus and many ornamental trees and shrubs. Its recorded host range includes most of the temperate fruit trees, but these are not important hosts in practice. In the EPPO region, avocados are a significant host, in the limited areas where they are grown.
GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION:
The geographical origin of P. cinnamomi is not clearly established. It was first described in Indonesia. Zentmyer suggests that the species is indigenous in Southeast Asia and in southern Africa, and spread across the Pacific to Latin America in the 18th Century. There is, however, no very clear evidence how such spread occurred. The appearance of the fungus in the EPPO region is much more recent. There is no useful purpose in giving a geographical distribution for countries where Phytophthora cinnamomi has been recorded on avocado, since the fungus is soil-borne, not host-specialized and can freely move from one crop to another. P. cinnamomi certainly already occurs on avocado in several Mediterranean countries.
EPPO region: Belgium, France (including Corsica), Germany, Greece (except Crete), Ireland, Israel, Italy, Morocco, Netherlands, Portugal (including Azores), Russia (European), Spain (including Canary Islands), Switzerland, Turkey, UK (England), Yugoslavia.
Asia: China (Jiangsu), India (Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, West Bengal), Indonesia (Java, Sumatra), Israel, Japan (Honshu, Ryukyu Archipelago), Malaysia (Peninsular, Sabah), Philippines, Taiwan, Turkey, Viet Nam.
Africa: Burundi, Cameroon, Congo, Côte d'Ivoire, Gabon, Guinea, Kenya, Madagascar, Morocco, Réunion, Rwanda, South Africa, Uganda, Zaire, Zambia, Zimbabwe. 2 Phytophthora cinnamomi
North America: Canada, Mexico, USA (Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Mississippi, Missouri, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia).
Central America and Caribbean: Barbados, Belize, Costa Rica, Cuba, Dominica, Dominican Republic, El Salvador, Guadeloupe, Guatemala, Haiti, Honduras, Jamaica, Martinique, Panama, Puerto Rico, St. Lucia, St. Vincent and Grenadines, Trinidad and Tobago.
South America: Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, Guyana, Peru, Venezuela.
Oceania: Australia, Cook Islands, Fiji, Micronesia, New Zealand, Papua New Guinea.
EU: Present.
Distribution map: See IMI
BIOLOGY:
Sporangia release motile zoospores into soil water, and these swim to small roots, encyst and germinate on the root surface. Penetration occurs within 24 h of germination. The fungus then spreads in the young feeder roots causing a rot which may extend into the base of the stem. Propagules may also be splashed onto and infect aerial parts of the plant. Temperature, moisture and pH all influence growth and reproduction of the fungus. Effects of these factors have been reviewed by Weste.
P. cinnamomi survives in dead plant material (survival influenced by soil matric potential) and can survive for long periods in this substrate (Shea et al., 1980). This saprophytic phase can allow an increase in the population of the pathogen. P. cinnamomi may also survive in the soil as mycelium, sporangia, zoospore cysts, chlamydospores and oospores and survival can be extended in the presence of an organic substrate (Weste & Vithanage, 1979). Mycelium of P. cinnamomi can survive for at least 6 years in moist soil (Zentmyer & Mircetich, 1966). Zoospore cysts can survive for at least 6 weeks at between -5 and -15 bar soil matric potential (MacDonald & Duniway, 1978). P. cinnamomi is heterothallic; oospores are very rare, and are slow to germinate. Varying germination periods may help to maintain a low but continuing population. Chlamydospore survival is also influenced by soil matric potential, and chlamydospores can survive for at least 6 years if soil moisture exceeds 3% (Zentmyer & Mircetich, 1966).
Chlamydospores form in soil, gravel or plant tissue during dry periods, germinate under favourable (moist) conditions and grow to form mycelia and sporangia or more chlamydospores. The latter may, in turn, remain dormant until conditions become suitable, then germinate to produce infective mycelia, sporangia and zoospores, or more chlamydospores. This cycle may continue for at least 5 years, provided there is a nutrient source (organic matter) and a non-competitive soil microflora.
Although P. cinnamomi was originally mainly reported in tropical and subtropical countries, it can apparently survive and develop in cooler countries, and does not seem to be obviously restricted by growing season or winter temperatures. Phytophthora cinnamomi 3
DETECTION AND IDENTIFICATION:
Symptoms
Phytophthora cinnamomi causes a rot of fine feeder roots, leading to dieback and death of host plants. Larger roots are only occasionally attacked. Other symptoms include wilt, stem cankers, decline in yield, decreased fruit size, gum exudation, collar rot (if infected through grafts near soil level).
Morphology
Hyphae with frequent nodules, up to 8 μm thick, hyphal swellings in clusters, typically spherical, average 42 μm diameter. Sporangiophores thin (3 μm), proliferating through the empty sporangium or occasionally branched. Sporangia broadly ellipsoid to ovoid, 57 x 33 μm, no papilla, slight apical thickening, not shed. Oogonia average 40 μm diameter, wall smooth, becoming yellowish with age. Antheridia amphigynous, 21-23 x 17 μm. A full description is given in Waterhouse & Waterston.
MEANS OF MOVEMENT AND DISPERSAL
On a local scale, the pathogen can be moved naturally by soil-splash, by wind-blown soil or debris, or by water movement and run-off in drainage/irrigation ditches. The most likely means of more distant movement is in contaminated soil or plant debris. Propagules can also be carried on machinery used for cultivation or harvesting and on seed. Movement of contaminated road gravel has resulted in initiation of new epidemics in Australia (Weste, 1975). Movement of contaminated soil with container-grown ornamentals can spread the pathogen to disease-free areas, and this is the most probable pathway for international spread. Avocado planting material (scions, seeds) should not normally carry the disease, but rootstock plants could do so, if these are traded as such.
PEST SIGNIFICANCE
Economic impact
The most significant food crop losses due to P. cinnamomi root rot occur in avocado, particularly in California, USA (Coit, 1928), Australia (Allen et al., 1980) and South Africa (Toerien, 1979). The disease on avocado has recently been reviewed by Coffey (1992). Severe epidemics of P. cinnamomi have caused extensive damage to Eucalyptus forests in Australia (Weste & Taylor, 1971). In temperate areas, P. cinnamomi causes serious damage to high-value ornamental trees and shrubs produced by the nursery stock industry (Smith, 1988). It is also reported to infect trees in amenity plantings, forests or orchards, but there is little or no quantitative record of this, which suggests that losses are only minor.
Control
Cultural control measures include alleviation of high soil moisture levels and improving aeration by increasing drainage, and attention to mineral nutrition. Elements of the soil microflora suppress P. cinnamomi in some soils and may be potential biocontrol agents (Stirling et al., 1992). These factors were reviewed by Weste (1983). Soil solarization also controls P. cinnamomi on young avocado plants (Kotzé & Darvas, 1983). Smith et al. (1983) reviewed the combination of measures for controlling the disease in nurseries. An integrated approach is generally taken to control P. cinnamomi on avocado (Coffey, 1987).
Chemical control is possible with systemic fungicides, particularly fosetyl-aluminium (and phosphonic acid) and metalaxyl (e.g. Whiley et al., 1986), applied by soil drench, foliar spray or trunk injection. Addition of elemental sulfur reduced disease incidence in pineapple, apparently through effects on soil pH (Pegg, 1977). 4 Phytophthora cinnamomi
Some rootstocks of avocado show tolerance (Kotzé & Darvas, 1983), and much work is reported on testing for resistance in avocado.
Phytosanitary risk
The pathogen is already present in much of the EPPO region, and it is not clear that there are any whole countries or large areas within countries where P. cinnamomi is known not to occur. As for other Phytophthora spp. on woody plants, low levels of infestation may be difficult to recognize (Tsao, 1990). P. cinnamomi has not been listed as a quarantine pest by EPPO or by any other regional plant protection organization. In a recent survey of possible new quarantine pests for the EPPO region, it was rated as doubtful. Avocado growers should certainly seek to exclude P. cinnamomi or keep populations down to low levels, by operating strict hygienic measures. However, it is not clear that imported material requires special measures, different from those taken domestically.
PHYTOSANITARY MEASURES
Hygienic precautions can be applied to exclude P. cinnamomi from a place of production (Smith, 1988). Unsterilized soil or growing medium, or farm machinery, should not be brought in. Introduced plants should be kept apart until their phytosanitary status has been checked. All propagation should be done from healthy plants or seed. Cultural measures should be taken to reduce the risk of spread in case of introduction. If land does become infested, incidence of P. cinnamomi can be reduced, if not necessarily eliminated, by leaving the land under non-susceptible crops for at least 4 years, and by applying various control measures (see Pest significance). Baum & Pinkas (1988) report on the first appearance of P. cinnamomi on avocado in Israel, and on the attempt to eradicate the disease, which was not successful.
REFERENCES:
Allen, R.N.; Pegg, K.G.; Forsberg, L.I.; Firth, D.J. (1980) Fungicidal control in pineapple and avocado of diseases caused by Phytophthora cinnamomi. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture and Animal Husbandry 20, 119-124.
Baum, D.; Pinkas, Y. (1988) [Phytophthora root rot six years after its first appearance in Israel]. Hassadeh 69, 274-277.
Coffey, M.D. (1987) Phytophthora root rot of avocado: an integrated approach to control in California. Plant Disease 71, 1046-1052.
Coffey, M.D. (1992) Phytophthora root rot of avocado. In: Plant diseases of international importance. Volume III. Diseases of fruit crops (Ed. by Kumar, J.; Chaube, H.S.; Singh, U.S.; Mukhopadhyay, A.N)., pp. 423-444. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, USA.
Coit, J.E. (1928) Pests and diseases of the avocado. California Avocado Society Yearbook, pp. 18-21.
IMI (1991) Distribution Maps of Plant Diseases No. 302 (edition 6). CAB International, Wallingford, UK.
Kotzé, J.M.; Darvas, J.M. (1983) Integrated control of avocado root rot. California Agricultural Society Yearbook 67, 83-86.
MacDonald, J.D.; Duniway, J.M. (1978) Influence of the matric and osmotic components of water potential on zoospore discharge in Phytophthora. Phytopathology 68, 751-757.
Pegg, K.G. (1977) Soil application of elemental sulphur as a control of Phytophthora cinnamomi root and heart rot of pineapple. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture and Husbandry 17, 859-865.
Shea, S.R.; Gillen, K.J.; Leppard, W.I. (1980) Seasonal variation in population levels of Phytophthora cinnamomi Rands in soil in diseased, freely-drained Eucalyptus marginata Sm. sites in the northern jarrah forests of south-western Australia. Protection Ecology 2, 135-156. Phytophthora cinnamomi 5
Smith, P.M. (1988) Phytophthora cinnamomi. In: European handbook of plant diseases (Ed. by Smith, I.M.; Dunez, J.; Lelliott, R.A.; Phillips, D.H.; Archer, S.A.), pp. 213-215. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford, UK.
Smith, P.M.; Brooks, A.V.; Evans, E.J.; Halstead, A.J. (1983) Pests and diseases of hardy nursery stock, bedding plants and turf. In: Pest and disease handbook, 2nd edition (Ed. by Scopes, N.; Ledieu, M.), pp. 473-556. British Crop Protection Council, Croydon, UK.
Stirling, A.M.; Hayward, A.C.; Pegg, K.G. (1992) Evaluation of the biological control potential of bacteria isolated from a soil suppressive to Phytophthora cinnamomi. Australasian Plant Pathology 21, 133-142.
Toerien, J.C. (1979) Seasonal incidence of ring-neck on avocados and possible causes. South African Avocado Growers' Association Research Report 3, 49-51.
Tsao, P.H. (1990) Why many phytophthora root rots and crown rots of tree and horticultural crops remain undetected. Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 20, 11-18.
Waterhouse, G.M.; Waterston, J.M. (1966). Phytophthora cinnamomi. CMI Descriptions of Pathogenic Fungi and Bacteria No. 113. CAB International, Wallingford, UK.
Weste, G. (1975). The distribution of Phytophthora cinnamomi within the National Park, Wilsons Promontory, Victoria. Australian Journal of Botany 23, 67-76.
Weste, G. (1983) Population dynamics and survival of Phytophthora. In: Phytophthora, its biology, taxonomy, ecology and pathology (Ed. by Erwin, D.C.; Bartnicki-Garcia, S.; Tsao, P.H.), pp. 237-258. American Phytopathological Society, St. Paul, USA.
Weste, G.; Taylor, P. (1971) The invasion of native forest by Phytophthora cinnamomi 1. Brisbane Ranges, Victoria. Australian Journal of Botany 19, 281-294.
Weste, G.; Vithanage, K. (1979) Survival of chlamydospores of Phytophthora cinnamomi in several non-sterile, host-free forest soils and gravels at different soil water potentials. Australian Journal of Botany 27, 1-9.
Whiley, A.W.; Pegg, K.G.; Saranah, J.B.; Forsberg, L.I. (1986) The control of phytophthora root rot of avocado with fungicides and the effect of this disease on water relations, yield and ring neck. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 26, 249-253.
Zentmyer, G.A. (1961) Avocado diseases in the Americas. Ceiba 9, 61-79.
Zentmyer, G.A. (1983) The world of Phytophthora. In: Phytophthora, its biology, taxonomy, ecology and pathology (Ed. by Erwin, D.C.; Bartnicki-Garcia, S.; Tsao, P.H.), pp. 1-8. American Phytopathological Society, St. Paul, USA.
Zentmyer, G.A. (1988) Origin and distribution of four species of Phytophthora. Transactions of the British Mycological Society 91, 367-378.
Zentmyer, G.A.; Mircetich, S.M. (1966) Saprophytism and persistence in soil by Phytophthora cinnamomi. Phytopathology 56, 710-712.
bio
Phytophthora cinnamomi
IDENTITY
Name: Phytophthora cinnamomi Rands
Taxonomic position: Fungi: Oomycetes: Peronosporales
Common names: Root and fruit rot of avocado (English)
Pourriture des racines, pourriture du collet (French)
Phytophthora-Wurzel und Stammfäule (German)
Podredumbre de la raíz (Spanish)
Bayer computer code: PHYTCN
EU Annex designation: II/B
HOSTS
The host range is very wide; P. cinnamomi is the most widely distributed Phytophthora species, with nearly 1000 host species (Zentmyer, 1983). The principal food crop hosts are avocados (Persea americana), with which the EU is exclusively concerned), and pineapples (Ananas comosus on which it causes root and heart rot. P. cinnamomi also attacks Castanea, Cinnamomum, Coniferales, Ericaceae (including Rhododendron spp.), Eucalyptus, Fagus, Juglans, Quercus and many ornamental trees and shrubs. Its recorded host range includes most of the temperate fruit trees, but these are not important hosts in practice. In the EPPO region, avocados are a significant host, in the limited areas where they are grown.
GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION
The geographical origin of P. cinnamomi is not clearly established. It was first described in Indonesia (Sumatra). Zentmyer (1988) suggests that the species is indigenous in Southeast Asia and in southern Africa, and spread across the Pacific to Latin America in the 18th Century. There is, however, no very clear evidence how such spread occurred. The appearance of the fungus in the EPPO region is much more recent. There is no useful purpose in giving a geographical distribution for countries where P. cinnamomi has been recorded on avocado, since the fungus is soil-borne, not host-specialized and can freely move from one crop to another. P. cinnamomi certainly already occurs on avocado in several Mediterranean countries.
EPPO region: Belgium, France (including Corsica), Germany, Greece (except Crete), Ireland, Israel, Italy, Morocco, Netherlands, Portugal (including Azores), Russia (European), Spain (including Canary Islands), Switzerland, Turkey, UK (England), Yugoslavia.
Asia: China (Jiangsu), India (Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, West Bengal), Indonesia (Java, Sumatra), Israel, Japan (Honshu, Ryukyu Archipelago), Malaysia (Peninsular, Sabah), Philippines, Taiwan, Turkey, Viet Nam.
Africa: Burundi, Cameroon, Congo, Côte d'Ivoire, Gabon, Guinea, Kenya, Madagascar, Morocco, Réunion, Rwanda, South Africa, Uganda, Zaire, Zambia, Zimbabwe. 2 Phytophthora cinnamomi
North America: Canada (British Columbia), Mexico, USA (Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Mississippi, Missouri, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia).
Central America and Caribbean: Barbados, Belize, Costa Rica, Cuba, Dominica, Dominican Republic, El Salvador, Guadeloupe, Guatemala, Haiti, Honduras, Jamaica, Martinique, Panama, Puerto Rico, St. Lucia, St. Vincent and Grenadines, Trinidad and Tobago.
South America: Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil (Goias, São Paulo), Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, Guyana, Peru, Venezuela.
Oceania: Australia (New South Wales, Northern Territory, Queensland, South Australia, Tasmania, Victoria, Western Australia), Cook Islands, Fiji, Micronesia, New Zealand, Papua New Guinea.
EU: Present.
Distribution map: See IMI (1991, No. 302).
BIOLOGY
Sporangia release motile zoospores into soil water, and these swim to small roots (a chemotactic response to root exudates), encyst and germinate on the root surface. Penetration occurs within 24 h of germination (Zentmyer, 1961). The fungus then spreads in the young feeder roots causing a rot which may extend into the base of the stem. Propagules may also be splashed onto and infect aerial parts of the plant. Temperature, moisture and pH all influence growth and reproduction of the fungus. Effects of these factors have been reviewed by Weste (1983).
P. cinnamomi survives in dead plant material (survival influenced by soil matric potential) and can survive for long periods in this substrate (Shea et al., 1980). This saprophytic phase can allow an increase in the population of the pathogen. P. cinnamomi may also survive in the soil as mycelium, sporangia, zoospore cysts, chlamydospores and oospores and survival can be extended in the presence of an organic substrate (Weste & Vithanage, 1979). Mycelium of P. cinnamomi can survive for at least 6 years in moist soil (Zentmyer & Mircetich, 1966). Zoospore cysts can survive for at least 6 weeks at between -5 and -15 bar soil matric potential (MacDonald & Duniway, 1978). P. cinnamomi is heterothallic; oospores are very rare, and are slow to germinate. Varying germination periods may help to maintain a low but continuing population. Chlamydospore survival is also influenced by soil matric potential, and chlamydospores can survive for at least 6 years if soil moisture exceeds 3% (Zentmyer & Mircetich, 1966).
Chlamydospores form in soil, gravel or plant tissue during dry periods, germinate under favourable (moist) conditions and grow to form mycelia and sporangia or more chlamydospores. The latter may, in turn, remain dormant until conditions become suitable, then germinate to produce infective mycelia, sporangia and zoospores, or more chlamydospores. This cycle may continue for at least 5 years, provided there is a nutrient source (organic matter) and a non-competitive soil microflora.
Although P. cinnamomi was originally mainly reported in tropical and subtropical countries, it can apparently survive and develop in cooler countries, and does not seem to be obviously restricted by growing season or winter temperatures. Phytophthora cinnamomi 3
DETECTION AND IDENTIFICATION
Symptoms
P. cinnamomi causes a rot of fine feeder roots, leading to dieback and death of host plants. Larger roots are only occasionally attacked. Other symptoms include wilt, stem cankers (with sudden death of tree), decline in yield, decreased fruit size, gum exudation, collar rot (if infected through grafts near soil level).
Morphology
Hyphae with frequent nodules, up to 8 μm thick, hyphal swellings in clusters, typically spherical, average 42 μm diameter. Sporangiophores thin (3 μm), proliferating through the empty sporangium or occasionally branched. Sporangia broadly ellipsoid to ovoid, 57 x 33 μm (up to 100 x 40 μm), no papilla, slight apical thickening, not shed. Oogonia average 40 μm diameter, wall smooth, becoming yellowish with age. Antheridia amphigynous, 21-23 x 17 μm. A full description is given in Waterhouse & Waterston (1966).
MEANS OF MOVEMENT AND DISPERSAL
On a local scale, the pathogen can be moved naturally by soil-splash, by wind-blown soil or debris, or by water movement and run-off in drainage/irrigation ditches. The most likely means of more distant movement is in contaminated soil or plant debris. Propagules can also be carried on machinery used for cultivation or harvesting and on seed. Movement of contaminated road gravel has resulted in initiation of new epidemics in Australia (Weste, 1975). Movement of contaminated soil with container-grown ornamentals can spread the pathogen to disease-free areas, and this is the most probable pathway for international spread. Avocado planting material (scions, seeds) should not normally carry the disease, but rootstock plants could do so, if these are traded as such.
PEST SIGNIFICANCE
Economic impact
The most significant food crop losses due to P. cinnamomi root rot occur in avocado, particularly in California, USA (Coit, 1928), Australia (Allen et al., 1980) and South Africa (Toerien, 1979). The disease on avocado has recently been reviewed by Coffey (1992). Severe epidemics of P. cinnamomi have caused extensive damage to Eucalyptus forests in Australia (Weste & Taylor, 1971). In temperate areas, P. cinnamomi causes serious damage to high-value ornamental trees and shrubs produced by the nursery stock industry (Smith, 1988). It is also reported to infect trees in amenity plantings, forests or orchards, but there is little or no quantitative record of this, which suggests that losses are only minor.
Control
Cultural control measures include alleviation of high soil moisture levels and improving aeration by increasing drainage, and attention to mineral nutrition. Elements of the soil microflora suppress P. cinnamomi in some soils and may be potential biocontrol agents (Stirling et al., 1992). These factors were reviewed by Weste (1983). Soil solarization also controls P. cinnamomi on young avocado plants (Kotzé & Darvas, 1983). Smith et al. (1983) reviewed the combination of measures for controlling the disease in nurseries. An integrated approach is generally taken to control P. cinnamomi on avocado (Coffey, 1987).
Chemical control is possible with systemic fungicides, particularly fosetyl-aluminium (and phosphonic acid) and metalaxyl (e.g. Whiley et al., 1986), applied by soil drench, foliar spray or trunk injection. Addition of elemental sulfur reduced disease incidence in pineapple, apparently through effects on soil pH (Pegg, 1977). 4 Phytophthora cinnamomi
Some rootstocks of avocado show tolerance (Kotzé & Darvas, 1983), and much work is reported on testing for resistance in avocado.
Phytosanitary risk
The pathogen is already present in much of the EPPO region, and it is not clear that there are any whole countries or large areas within countries where P. cinnamomi is known not to occur. As for other Phytophthora spp. on woody plants, low levels of infestation may be difficult to recognize (Tsao, 1990). P. cinnamomi has not been listed as a quarantine pest by EPPO or by any other regional plant protection organization. In a recent survey of possible new quarantine pests for the EPPO region, it was rated as doubtful. Avocado growers should certainly seek to exclude P. cinnamomi or keep populations down to low levels, by operating strict hygienic measures. However, it is not clear that imported material requires special measures, different from those taken domestically.
PHYTOSANITARY MEASURES
Hygienic precautions can be applied to exclude P. cinnamomi from a place of production (Smith, 1988). Unsterilized soil or growing medium, or farm machinery, should not be brought in. Introduced plants should be kept apart until their phytosanitary status has been checked. All propagation should be done from healthy plants or seed. Cultural measures should be taken to reduce the risk of spread in case of introduction. If land does become infested, incidence of P. cinnamomi can be reduced, if not necessarily eliminated, by leaving the land under non-susceptible crops for at least 4 years, and by applying various control measures (see Pest significance). Baum & Pinkas (1988) report on the first appearance of P. cinnamomi on avocado in Israel, and on the attempt to eradicate the disease, which was not successful.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Allen, R.N.; Pegg, K.G.; Forsberg, L.I.; Firth, D.J. (1980) Fungicidal control in pineapple and avocado of diseases caused by Phytophthora cinnamomi. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture and Animal Husbandry 20, 119-124.
Baum, D.; Pinkas, Y. (1988) [Phytophthora root rot six years after its first appearance in Israel]. Hassadeh 69, 274-277.
Coffey, M.D. (1987) Phytophthora root rot of avocado: an integrated approach to control in California. Plant Disease 71, 1046-1052.
Coffey, M.D. (1992) Phytophthora root rot of avocado. In: Plant diseases of international importance. Volume III. Diseases of fruit crops (Ed. by Kumar, J.; Chaube, H.S.; Singh, U.S.; Mukhopadhyay, A.N)., pp. 423-444. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, USA.
Coit, J.E. (1928) Pests and diseases of the avocado. California Avocado Society Yearbook, pp. 18-21.
IMI (1991) Distribution Maps of Plant Diseases No. 302 (edition 6). CAB International, Wallingford, UK.
Kotzé, J.M.; Darvas, J.M. (1983) Integrated control of avocado root rot. California Agricultural Society Yearbook 67, 83-86.
MacDonald, J.D.; Duniway, J.M. (1978) Influence of the matric and osmotic components of water potential on zoospore discharge in Phytophthora. Phytopathology 68, 751-757.
Pegg, K.G. (1977) Soil application of elemental sulphur as a control of Phytophthora cinnamomi root and heart rot of pineapple. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture and Husbandry 17, 859-865.
Shea, S.R.; Gillen, K.J.; Leppard, W.I. (1980) Seasonal variation in population levels of Phytophthora cinnamomi Rands in soil in diseased, freely-drained Eucalyptus marginata Sm. sites in the northern jarrah forests of south-western Australia. Protection Ecology 2, 135-156. Phytophthora cinnamomi 5
Smith, P.M. (1988) Phytophthora cinnamomi. In: European handbook of plant diseases (Ed. by Smith, I.M.; Dunez, J.; Lelliott, R.A.; Phillips, D.H.; Archer, S.A.), pp. 213-215. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford, UK.
Smith, P.M.; Brooks, A.V.; Evans, E.J.; Halstead, A.J. (1983) Pests and diseases of hardy nursery stock, bedding plants and turf. In: Pest and disease handbook, 2nd edition (Ed. by Scopes, N.; Ledieu, M.), pp. 473-556. British Crop Protection Council, Croydon, UK.
Stirling, A.M.; Hayward, A.C.; Pegg, K.G. (1992) Evaluation of the biological control potential of bacteria isolated from a soil suppressive to Phytophthora cinnamomi. Australasian Plant Pathology 21, 133-142.
Toerien, J.C. (1979) Seasonal incidence of ring-neck on avocados and possible causes. South African Avocado Growers' Association Research Report 3, 49-51.
Tsao, P.H. (1990) Why many phytophthora root rots and crown rots of tree and horticultural crops remain undetected. Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 20, 11-18.
Waterhouse, G.M.; Waterston, J.M. (1966). Phytophthora cinnamomi. CMI Descriptions of Pathogenic Fungi and Bacteria No. 113. CAB International, Wallingford, UK.
Weste, G. (1975). The distribution of Phytophthora cinnamomi within the National Park, Wilsons Promontory, Victoria. Australian Journal of Botany 23, 67-76.
Weste, G. (1983) Population dynamics and survival of Phytophthora. In: Phytophthora, its biology, taxonomy, ecology and pathology (Ed. by Erwin, D.C.; Bartnicki-Garcia, S.; Tsao, P.H.), pp. 237-258. American Phytopathological Society, St. Paul, USA.
Weste, G.; Taylor, P. (1971) The invasion of native forest by Phytophthora cinnamomi 1. Brisbane Ranges, Victoria. Australian Journal of Botany 19, 281-294.
Weste, G.; Vithanage, K. (1979) Survival of chlamydospores of Phytophthora cinnamomi in several non-sterile, host-free forest soils and gravels at different soil water potentials. Australian Journal of Botany 27, 1-9.
Whiley, A.W.; Pegg, K.G.; Saranah, J.B.; Forsberg, L.I. (1986) The control of phytophthora root rot of avocado with fungicides and the effect of this disease on water relations, yield and ring neck. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 26, 249-253.
Zentmyer, G.A. (1961) Avocado diseases in the Americas. Ceiba 9, 61-79.
Zentmyer, G.A. (1983) The world of Phytophthora. In: Phytophthora, its biology, taxonomy, ecology and pathology (Ed. by Erwin, D.C.; Bartnicki-Garcia, S.; Tsao, P.H.), pp. 1-8. American Phytopathological Society, St. Paul, USA.
Zentmyer, G.A. (1988) Origin and distribution of four species of Phytophthora. Transactions of the British Mycological Society 91, 367-378.
Zentmyer, G.A.; Mircetich, S.M. (1966) Saprophytism and persistence in soil by Phytophthora cinnamomi. Phytopathology 56, 710-712.
IDENTITY
Name: Phytophthora cinnamomi Rands
Taxonomic position: Fungi: Oomycetes: Peronosporales
Common names: Root and fruit rot of avocado (English)
Pourriture des racines, pourriture du collet (French)
Phytophthora-Wurzel und Stammfäule (German)
Podredumbre de la raíz (Spanish)
Bayer computer code: PHYTCN
EU Annex designation: II/B
HOSTS
The host range is very wide; P. cinnamomi is the most widely distributed Phytophthora species, with nearly 1000 host species (Zentmyer, 1983). The principal food crop hosts are avocados (Persea americana), with which the EU is exclusively concerned), and pineapples (Ananas comosus on which it causes root and heart rot. P. cinnamomi also attacks Castanea, Cinnamomum, Coniferales, Ericaceae (including Rhododendron spp.), Eucalyptus, Fagus, Juglans, Quercus and many ornamental trees and shrubs. Its recorded host range includes most of the temperate fruit trees, but these are not important hosts in practice. In the EPPO region, avocados are a significant host, in the limited areas where they are grown.
GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION
The geographical origin of P. cinnamomi is not clearly established. It was first described in Indonesia (Sumatra). Zentmyer (1988) suggests that the species is indigenous in Southeast Asia and in southern Africa, and spread across the Pacific to Latin America in the 18th Century. There is, however, no very clear evidence how such spread occurred. The appearance of the fungus in the EPPO region is much more recent. There is no useful purpose in giving a geographical distribution for countries where P. cinnamomi has been recorded on avocado, since the fungus is soil-borne, not host-specialized and can freely move from one crop to another. P. cinnamomi certainly already occurs on avocado in several Mediterranean countries.
EPPO region: Belgium, France (including Corsica), Germany, Greece (except Crete), Ireland, Israel, Italy, Morocco, Netherlands, Portugal (including Azores), Russia (European), Spain (including Canary Islands), Switzerland, Turkey, UK (England), Yugoslavia.
Asia: China (Jiangsu), India (Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, West Bengal), Indonesia (Java, Sumatra), Israel, Japan (Honshu, Ryukyu Archipelago), Malaysia (Peninsular, Sabah), Philippines, Taiwan, Turkey, Viet Nam.
Africa: Burundi, Cameroon, Congo, Côte d'Ivoire, Gabon, Guinea, Kenya, Madagascar, Morocco, Réunion, Rwanda, South Africa, Uganda, Zaire, Zambia, Zimbabwe. 2 Phytophthora cinnamomi
North America: Canada (British Columbia), Mexico, USA (Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Mississippi, Missouri, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia).
Central America and Caribbean: Barbados, Belize, Costa Rica, Cuba, Dominica, Dominican Republic, El Salvador, Guadeloupe, Guatemala, Haiti, Honduras, Jamaica, Martinique, Panama, Puerto Rico, St. Lucia, St. Vincent and Grenadines, Trinidad and Tobago.
South America: Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil (Goias, São Paulo), Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, Guyana, Peru, Venezuela.
Oceania: Australia (New South Wales, Northern Territory, Queensland, South Australia, Tasmania, Victoria, Western Australia), Cook Islands, Fiji, Micronesia, New Zealand, Papua New Guinea.
EU: Present.
Distribution map: See IMI (1991, No. 302).
BIOLOGY
Sporangia release motile zoospores into soil water, and these swim to small roots (a chemotactic response to root exudates), encyst and germinate on the root surface. Penetration occurs within 24 h of germination (Zentmyer, 1961). The fungus then spreads in the young feeder roots causing a rot which may extend into the base of the stem. Propagules may also be splashed onto and infect aerial parts of the plant. Temperature, moisture and pH all influence growth and reproduction of the fungus. Effects of these factors have been reviewed by Weste (1983).
P. cinnamomi survives in dead plant material (survival influenced by soil matric potential) and can survive for long periods in this substrate (Shea et al., 1980). This saprophytic phase can allow an increase in the population of the pathogen. P. cinnamomi may also survive in the soil as mycelium, sporangia, zoospore cysts, chlamydospores and oospores and survival can be extended in the presence of an organic substrate (Weste & Vithanage, 1979). Mycelium of P. cinnamomi can survive for at least 6 years in moist soil (Zentmyer & Mircetich, 1966). Zoospore cysts can survive for at least 6 weeks at between -5 and -15 bar soil matric potential (MacDonald & Duniway, 1978). P. cinnamomi is heterothallic; oospores are very rare, and are slow to germinate. Varying germination periods may help to maintain a low but continuing population. Chlamydospore survival is also influenced by soil matric potential, and chlamydospores can survive for at least 6 years if soil moisture exceeds 3% (Zentmyer & Mircetich, 1966).
Chlamydospores form in soil, gravel or plant tissue during dry periods, germinate under favourable (moist) conditions and grow to form mycelia and sporangia or more chlamydospores. The latter may, in turn, remain dormant until conditions become suitable, then germinate to produce infective mycelia, sporangia and zoospores, or more chlamydospores. This cycle may continue for at least 5 years, provided there is a nutrient source (organic matter) and a non-competitive soil microflora.
Although P. cinnamomi was originally mainly reported in tropical and subtropical countries, it can apparently survive and develop in cooler countries, and does not seem to be obviously restricted by growing season or winter temperatures. Phytophthora cinnamomi 3
DETECTION AND IDENTIFICATION
Symptoms
P. cinnamomi causes a rot of fine feeder roots, leading to dieback and death of host plants. Larger roots are only occasionally attacked. Other symptoms include wilt, stem cankers (with sudden death of tree), decline in yield, decreased fruit size, gum exudation, collar rot (if infected through grafts near soil level).
Morphology
Hyphae with frequent nodules, up to 8 μm thick, hyphal swellings in clusters, typically spherical, average 42 μm diameter. Sporangiophores thin (3 μm), proliferating through the empty sporangium or occasionally branched. Sporangia broadly ellipsoid to ovoid, 57 x 33 μm (up to 100 x 40 μm), no papilla, slight apical thickening, not shed. Oogonia average 40 μm diameter, wall smooth, becoming yellowish with age. Antheridia amphigynous, 21-23 x 17 μm. A full description is given in Waterhouse & Waterston (1966).
MEANS OF MOVEMENT AND DISPERSAL
On a local scale, the pathogen can be moved naturally by soil-splash, by wind-blown soil or debris, or by water movement and run-off in drainage/irrigation ditches. The most likely means of more distant movement is in contaminated soil or plant debris. Propagules can also be carried on machinery used for cultivation or harvesting and on seed. Movement of contaminated road gravel has resulted in initiation of new epidemics in Australia (Weste, 1975). Movement of contaminated soil with container-grown ornamentals can spread the pathogen to disease-free areas, and this is the most probable pathway for international spread. Avocado planting material (scions, seeds) should not normally carry the disease, but rootstock plants could do so, if these are traded as such.
PEST SIGNIFICANCE
Economic impact
The most significant food crop losses due to P. cinnamomi root rot occur in avocado, particularly in California, USA (Coit, 1928), Australia (Allen et al., 1980) and South Africa (Toerien, 1979). The disease on avocado has recently been reviewed by Coffey (1992). Severe epidemics of P. cinnamomi have caused extensive damage to Eucalyptus forests in Australia (Weste & Taylor, 1971). In temperate areas, P. cinnamomi causes serious damage to high-value ornamental trees and shrubs produced by the nursery stock industry (Smith, 1988). It is also reported to infect trees in amenity plantings, forests or orchards, but there is little or no quantitative record of this, which suggests that losses are only minor.
Control
Cultural control measures include alleviation of high soil moisture levels and improving aeration by increasing drainage, and attention to mineral nutrition. Elements of the soil microflora suppress P. cinnamomi in some soils and may be potential biocontrol agents (Stirling et al., 1992). These factors were reviewed by Weste (1983). Soil solarization also controls P. cinnamomi on young avocado plants (Kotzé & Darvas, 1983). Smith et al. (1983) reviewed the combination of measures for controlling the disease in nurseries. An integrated approach is generally taken to control P. cinnamomi on avocado (Coffey, 1987).
Chemical control is possible with systemic fungicides, particularly fosetyl-aluminium (and phosphonic acid) and metalaxyl (e.g. Whiley et al., 1986), applied by soil drench, foliar spray or trunk injection. Addition of elemental sulfur reduced disease incidence in pineapple, apparently through effects on soil pH (Pegg, 1977). 4 Phytophthora cinnamomi
Some rootstocks of avocado show tolerance (Kotzé & Darvas, 1983), and much work is reported on testing for resistance in avocado.
Phytosanitary risk
The pathogen is already present in much of the EPPO region, and it is not clear that there are any whole countries or large areas within countries where P. cinnamomi is known not to occur. As for other Phytophthora spp. on woody plants, low levels of infestation may be difficult to recognize (Tsao, 1990). P. cinnamomi has not been listed as a quarantine pest by EPPO or by any other regional plant protection organization. In a recent survey of possible new quarantine pests for the EPPO region, it was rated as doubtful. Avocado growers should certainly seek to exclude P. cinnamomi or keep populations down to low levels, by operating strict hygienic measures. However, it is not clear that imported material requires special measures, different from those taken domestically.
PHYTOSANITARY MEASURES
Hygienic precautions can be applied to exclude P. cinnamomi from a place of production (Smith, 1988). Unsterilized soil or growing medium, or farm machinery, should not be brought in. Introduced plants should be kept apart until their phytosanitary status has been checked. All propagation should be done from healthy plants or seed. Cultural measures should be taken to reduce the risk of spread in case of introduction. If land does become infested, incidence of P. cinnamomi can be reduced, if not necessarily eliminated, by leaving the land under non-susceptible crops for at least 4 years, and by applying various control measures (see Pest significance). Baum & Pinkas (1988) report on the first appearance of P. cinnamomi on avocado in Israel, and on the attempt to eradicate the disease, which was not successful.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Allen, R.N.; Pegg, K.G.; Forsberg, L.I.; Firth, D.J. (1980) Fungicidal control in pineapple and avocado of diseases caused by Phytophthora cinnamomi. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture and Animal Husbandry 20, 119-124.
Baum, D.; Pinkas, Y. (1988) [Phytophthora root rot six years after its first appearance in Israel]. Hassadeh 69, 274-277.
Coffey, M.D. (1987) Phytophthora root rot of avocado: an integrated approach to control in California. Plant Disease 71, 1046-1052.
Coffey, M.D. (1992) Phytophthora root rot of avocado. In: Plant diseases of international importance. Volume III. Diseases of fruit crops (Ed. by Kumar, J.; Chaube, H.S.; Singh, U.S.; Mukhopadhyay, A.N)., pp. 423-444. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, USA.
Coit, J.E. (1928) Pests and diseases of the avocado. California Avocado Society Yearbook, pp. 18-21.
IMI (1991) Distribution Maps of Plant Diseases No. 302 (edition 6). CAB International, Wallingford, UK.
Kotzé, J.M.; Darvas, J.M. (1983) Integrated control of avocado root rot. California Agricultural Society Yearbook 67, 83-86.
MacDonald, J.D.; Duniway, J.M. (1978) Influence of the matric and osmotic components of water potential on zoospore discharge in Phytophthora. Phytopathology 68, 751-757.
Pegg, K.G. (1977) Soil application of elemental sulphur as a control of Phytophthora cinnamomi root and heart rot of pineapple. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture and Husbandry 17, 859-865.
Shea, S.R.; Gillen, K.J.; Leppard, W.I. (1980) Seasonal variation in population levels of Phytophthora cinnamomi Rands in soil in diseased, freely-drained Eucalyptus marginata Sm. sites in the northern jarrah forests of south-western Australia. Protection Ecology 2, 135-156. Phytophthora cinnamomi 5
Smith, P.M. (1988) Phytophthora cinnamomi. In: European handbook of plant diseases (Ed. by Smith, I.M.; Dunez, J.; Lelliott, R.A.; Phillips, D.H.; Archer, S.A.), pp. 213-215. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford, UK.
Smith, P.M.; Brooks, A.V.; Evans, E.J.; Halstead, A.J. (1983) Pests and diseases of hardy nursery stock, bedding plants and turf. In: Pest and disease handbook, 2nd edition (Ed. by Scopes, N.; Ledieu, M.), pp. 473-556. British Crop Protection Council, Croydon, UK.
Stirling, A.M.; Hayward, A.C.; Pegg, K.G. (1992) Evaluation of the biological control potential of bacteria isolated from a soil suppressive to Phytophthora cinnamomi. Australasian Plant Pathology 21, 133-142.
Toerien, J.C. (1979) Seasonal incidence of ring-neck on avocados and possible causes. South African Avocado Growers' Association Research Report 3, 49-51.
Tsao, P.H. (1990) Why many phytophthora root rots and crown rots of tree and horticultural crops remain undetected. Bulletin OEPP/EPPO Bulletin 20, 11-18.
Waterhouse, G.M.; Waterston, J.M. (1966). Phytophthora cinnamomi. CMI Descriptions of Pathogenic Fungi and Bacteria No. 113. CAB International, Wallingford, UK.
Weste, G. (1975). The distribution of Phytophthora cinnamomi within the National Park, Wilsons Promontory, Victoria. Australian Journal of Botany 23, 67-76.
Weste, G. (1983) Population dynamics and survival of Phytophthora. In: Phytophthora, its biology, taxonomy, ecology and pathology (Ed. by Erwin, D.C.; Bartnicki-Garcia, S.; Tsao, P.H.), pp. 237-258. American Phytopathological Society, St. Paul, USA.
Weste, G.; Taylor, P. (1971) The invasion of native forest by Phytophthora cinnamomi 1. Brisbane Ranges, Victoria. Australian Journal of Botany 19, 281-294.
Weste, G.; Vithanage, K. (1979) Survival of chlamydospores of Phytophthora cinnamomi in several non-sterile, host-free forest soils and gravels at different soil water potentials. Australian Journal of Botany 27, 1-9.
Whiley, A.W.; Pegg, K.G.; Saranah, J.B.; Forsberg, L.I. (1986) The control of phytophthora root rot of avocado with fungicides and the effect of this disease on water relations, yield and ring neck. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 26, 249-253.
Zentmyer, G.A. (1961) Avocado diseases in the Americas. Ceiba 9, 61-79.
Zentmyer, G.A. (1983) The world of Phytophthora. In: Phytophthora, its biology, taxonomy, ecology and pathology (Ed. by Erwin, D.C.; Bartnicki-Garcia, S.; Tsao, P.H.), pp. 1-8. American Phytopathological Society, St. Paul, USA.
Zentmyer, G.A. (1988) Origin and distribution of four species of Phytophthora. Transactions of the British Mycological Society 91, 367-378.
Zentmyer, G.A.; Mircetich, S.M. (1966) Saprophytism and persistence in soil by Phytophthora cinnamomi. Phytopathology 56, 710-712.
ha
Introduction of Hazard Identification:
Safety risk assessment is one of the processes in a Safety Management System (SMS) and an important element of the safety risk assessment is the identification of hazards.
A hazard can be considered as a dormant potential for harm which is present in one form or another within the aviation system or its environment. This potential for harm may be in the form of a natural hazard such as terrain, or a technical hazard such as wrong runway markings.
The use of the term ‘hazard’ in the formal risk assessment context originated in the nuclear and chemical industries for which a wide range of different types of ‘hazards’ are present all of the time .The ‘control’ of these hazards (containment, separation etc.) and the ‘mitigation’ of their consequences (gas detection, plant shutdown etc.) should a failure condition arise is the subject of safety risk assessment and safety risk management processes.
A condition, object, activity or event with the potential of causing injuries to personnel, damage to equipment or structures, loss of material, or reduction of ability to perform a prescribed function.
Safety risk assessment is one of the functions in a Safety Management System and an important element of safety risk assessment is the identification of hazards.
A hazard can be considered as a dormant potential for harm which is present in one form or another within the aviation system or its environment. This potential for harm may be in the
form of a natural hazard such as terrain, or a technical hazard such as wrong runway
markings.
An SMS is a systematic and organised approach to managing safety, including the necessary
organisational structures, accountabilities, policies and procedures. The component of SMS
within which hazards identification takes place is safety risk assessment and this forms part of
an overall safety risk management process.
Safety risk assessment can be performed on steady-state operations to provide assurance that
the risks associated with day-to-day operations remain tolerably safe. It can also be performed
on proposed changes to a system or operation to ensure that the risks from any additional
hazards or any impacts on existing hazards, introduced by the change remain acceptably safe.
Safety risk assessment features 8 steps:
1. System / operation description
2. Hazards identification processes
3. Consequence analysis
4. Causal analysis
5. Evaluation of risk
6. Mitigation of risk
7. Approval of residual risk
8. Safety assessment documentation
Fig1: Definition of hazard identification
Risk Controls (Barriers and Mitigation)
A system, activity, action or procedure that is put in place to reduce the risks associated with a
hazard. Mitigation may include:
• elimination of the hazard (preferred),
• reduction in the frequency of the hazard (barriers),
• reduction in the likelihood of the outcomes of the hazard (outcome mitigation),
• reduction of the severity of the outcomes of the hazard (consequence mitigation).
Risk
The combination of the predicted frequency and severity of the consequences of hazard(s)
taking into account all of the potential outcomes.
Safety Risk Management
The identification of hazards associated with the day-to-day operations of an organisation, or
associated with changes to the operations of an organisation; the assessment of the risks
associated with those hazards; and the implementation and management of measures to
reduce those risks to an acceptable level (hazard removal; or the application of barriers and/or
mitigations – i.e. risk control).
The above definitions are illustrated diagrammatically in Figure 1 which is referred to in some
literature as a Bow-Tie diagram. ‘Bow-tie’ also refers to the methodology used to build
such diagram. Some examples of the use of the terminology are also provided in Tables 1 to 4.
The method for building a bow-tie involves asking a structured set of questions in a logical
sequence. The completed Bow-Tie illustrates the hazard, the undesirable event, the safety
events and potential outcomes, and the risk controls put in place to minimise the risk.
Risk management is about controlling risks. This is done by placing barriers to prevent certain
undesirable events from happening. A control can be any measure taken that acts against
some undesirable force or intention, in order to maintain a desired state. In the Bow-Tie
methodology there are preventive or proactive barriers (on the left side of the Undesirable
Event) that prevent the Undesirable Event from happening. There are also corrective or
reactive controls (on the right side of the Undesirable Event) that prevent the Undesirable
Event from resulting into unwanted Outcomes or reduce the consequence severity of the
Outcomes.
3 Hazards identification in Practice
Hazards may be identified through a data-driven (quantitative) methodology or qualitative
process such as discussions, interviews and brainstorming.
3.1 Data Driven Methodologies
In a data-driven approach, hazards are identified and recorded through a systematic process
which allows for traceability and further analysis.
There are various types of recorded observations which may be used to identify hazards.
Sources for hazards identification can be Flight Data Monitoring (FDM), company audits,
staff surveys, hazard reports and others. Investigation and reports of past occurrences
may provide rich material as to existing hazards as well as, alternative to these, hazards which
may arise. For example, an occurrence report may identify the hazard of standing water
affecting the integrity of landing aid equipment at an airport, but through this report other
hazards which may affect this equipment may also be identified.
Furthermore, real-time and non real-time simulations may be used to identify likely hazards
and their interactions. Using simulation modelling it
may be easier to identify potential hazards and their potential outcomes.
3.2 Qualitative Methodologies
Hazards may be identified through a qualitative process, either formal (part of safety
assessment) or informal based on discussions, interviews and brainstorming. Informal
qualitative methodologies are heuristic processes based on expert judgement. They often allow
identifying hazards that other approaches can’t detect. Using both approaches in combination
will provide better and more comprehensive results.
Within published literature, it is recognised that hazards identification must be done
methodically in order to ensure that all areas of operation where hazards may exist have been
identified. It is recommended that among others; design, organisational, work environment
factors, as well as procedures and operating practices are taken into account in the
identification process.
Existing material should be reviewed with the aim of identifying gaps or hazards. The UK CAA
suggests a brainstorming exercise, which will allow participants to
identify hazards within the organisation. The hazard control Toolbox
suggests that the identification of the hazards may be
done by individual or group-based assessors.
The main challenge for individual and group-based brainstorming sessions involves the
identification of hazards which exist but are difficult to think of. Some approaches have been
developed to cover what might be termed ‘unimaginable hazards’.
Unimaginable Hazards
One of the most common ways of identifying hazards other than from occurrence reports is to
conduct functional hazard assessments. In such functional hazard assessments, failures of
prescribed or intended system functions or operational procedures, the operational
consequences of these failures, and the potential effects on the safety of the operation are
identified. It is however a well established fact that some hazards are hard or even impossible
to identify using functional hazard identification sessions. Such hazards are called
unimaginable hazards.
One reason why not all hazards may be identified through a functional approach is that there
may be hazards associated with a system functioning well, for example when operators
become overly reliant on a well-functioning alerting system. Another reason is that some
hazards may not be associated with functional failures, such as those associated with
situational awareness problems. Also, sometimes functions relevant for the safety of the
operations are implicit and go unnoticed, or the available description of the system or
operation involved is otherwise not complete.
This means that, in order to get a complete picture of the relevant hazards, “logical thinking”
from the functional failure point of view must be enhanced by creative input of operational
experts. Such input is obtained through hazard identification brainstorming sessions that are
designed, organised and conducted in a specific manner. Guidance for such hazard
identification brainstorming sessions may be found.
Getting an as complete as possible overview of the relevant hazards is essential of course, as
the risks associated with hazards that go unnoticed, cannot be managed.
4 Specific Tools and Techniques for Hazards Identification
This section provides a summary of a number of tools and techniques that can be used for
hazards identification. The various techniques are described below together with a brief
overview of their advantages and disadvantages.
It should be remembered that any system or operation comprises:
• people;
• procedures;
• equipment; and
• an environment of operation
All these elements must be considered during hazards identification.
Hazards identification techniques require a definition of the System / Operation, its
environment of operation and its interactions to have been completed prior to undertaking the
task (safety risk assessment Step 1: System/Operation description). This System / Operation
definition may take different forms depending on the specific technique and type of system.
The definition may be:
• Functional
• Operational
• Process
• Scenario based
4.1 Brainstorming
Brainstorming is an unbounded but facilitated discussion within a group of experts. A
facilitator prepares prompts or issues ahead of the group session and then encourages
imaginative thinking and discussion between group members during the session. The
facilitator initiates a thread of discussion and there are no rules as to what is in or out of scope
from the subsequent discussion. All contributions are accepted and recorded and no view is
challenged or criticised. This provides an environment in which the experts feel comfortable in
thinking laterally.
Advantages
• Good for identifying new hazards in novel systems.
• Involves all key stakeholders.
• Relatively quick and easy to undertake.
• Can be applied to a wide range of types of systems.
Disadvantages
• Relatively unstructured and therefore not necessarily comprehensive.
• Depends on the expertise and profile of the participants
• May be susceptible to the influence of group dynamics.
• Can rely heavily on the skills of the facilitator for success.
Hazard and Operability (HAZOP) Study
HAZOP is a systematic and structured approach using parameter and deviation guidewords.
The technique relies on a very detailed system description being available for study and
usually involves breaking down the system into well defined subsystems and
functional or process flows between subsystems. Each element of the system is then
subjected to discussion within a multidisciplinary group of experts against the various
combinations of the guidewords and deviations.
The group discussion is facilitated by a Chairman and the results of the discussion recorded by
a Secretary together including any hazards identified when a particular guideword and
deviation combination is discussed. Where a particular guideword and deviation combination
does not produce any hazards, or is not thought credible, this should also be recorded to
demonstrate completeness.
The guidewords and deviations must be prepared in advance by the HAZOP Chairman and may
need to be tailored to the system or operation being studied.
In an aviation context, typical guidewords might include:
• Detection
• Co-ordination
• Notification
• Transmission
• Clearance
• Authorisation
• Selection
• Transcription
• Turn
• Climb
• Descend
• Speed
• Read-back
• Monitoring
• Signage
• Handover
• Supervision
Typical deviations might include:
• Too soon / early
• Too late
• Too much
• Too little
• Too high
• Too low
• Missing
• Twice / repeated
• Out of sequence
• Ambiguous
• Reverse / inverted
Advantages
• Systematic and rigorous.
• Involves interaction of views from multidisciplinary experts.
• Can be applied to a wide range of types of system.
• Creates a detailed and auditable record of the hazards identification process.
Disadvantages
• Requires a considerable amount of preparation.
• Can rely heavily on the skills of the HAZOP Chairman
• Can be time consuming and therefore expensive.
• Can inhibit imaginative thinking and so certain kinds of hazards.
Future Hazards Identification through the FAST method
Identification of future hazards often relies on expert judgement and some sort of
‘instrumented’ brainstorming.
There are only few methods available for future hazards identification. The method developed
by the Future Aviation Safety Team (FAST) is one of these. This team created by the JSSI is
now associated to ECAST, the commercial aviation safety team of the ESSI.
The FAST method (Ref. 8 - FAST method) is a “prognostic” or “predictive” approach
aimed at discovering future hazards arising as a consequence of future changes
introduced inside or outside the global aviation system and of their interaction, and
subsequently develop and implement mitigating actions.
The FAST team has built and maintains a list of 200+ Areas of Changes (AoCs) affecting the
global Aviation and ATM system. This list is used for identification of future hazards.
This list can be augmented by a more specific list of changes identified by the method user
(airline, ANSP, maintenance organisation, manufacturer, authority, etc.) that specifically
affects its activities. A list of local changes is likely to feature proprietary information regarding
for instance new market strategy, new organisation, new staff policy, opening of a new route,
etc., depending on the method user’s profile.
Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA)
FMEA is a ‘bottom up’ technique that is used to consider ways in which the basic
components of a system can fail to perform their design intent. This could either be at
an equipment level or at a functional level. The technique relies on a detailed system
description and considers the ways in which each sub-component of the system could fail to
meet its design intent and what the consequences would be on the overall system.
For each sub-component of a system an FMEA considers:
• All the potential ways that the component could fail.
• The effects that each of these failures would have on the system behaviour.
• The possible causes of the various failure modes.
• How the failures might be mitigated within the system or its environment.
Behaviours at the system level arising from the sub-component failures which have a safety
consequence are thus identified as hazards. The system level at which the analysis is applied
can vary and is determined by the level of detail of the system description used to support the
analysis. Depending on the nature and complexity of the system, the analysis could be
undertaken by an individual system expert or by a team of system experts acting in group
session.
Advantages
• Systematic and rigorous.
• Creates a detailed and auditable record of the hazards identification process.
• Can be applied to a wide range of types of system.
Disadvantages
• Only really considers hazards arising from single point failure modes rather than
combinations of failures.
• Relies on people with detailed system knowledge.
• Can be time consuming and expensive.
Safety risk assessment is one of the processes in a Safety Management System (SMS) and an important element of the safety risk assessment is the identification of hazards.
A hazard can be considered as a dormant potential for harm which is present in one form or another within the aviation system or its environment. This potential for harm may be in the form of a natural hazard such as terrain, or a technical hazard such as wrong runway markings.
The use of the term ‘hazard’ in the formal risk assessment context originated in the nuclear and chemical industries for which a wide range of different types of ‘hazards’ are present all of the time .The ‘control’ of these hazards (containment, separation etc.) and the ‘mitigation’ of their consequences (gas detection, plant shutdown etc.) should a failure condition arise is the subject of safety risk assessment and safety risk management processes.
A condition, object, activity or event with the potential of causing injuries to personnel, damage to equipment or structures, loss of material, or reduction of ability to perform a prescribed function.
Safety risk assessment is one of the functions in a Safety Management System and an important element of safety risk assessment is the identification of hazards.
A hazard can be considered as a dormant potential for harm which is present in one form or another within the aviation system or its environment. This potential for harm may be in the
form of a natural hazard such as terrain, or a technical hazard such as wrong runway
markings.
An SMS is a systematic and organised approach to managing safety, including the necessary
organisational structures, accountabilities, policies and procedures. The component of SMS
within which hazards identification takes place is safety risk assessment and this forms part of
an overall safety risk management process.
Safety risk assessment can be performed on steady-state operations to provide assurance that
the risks associated with day-to-day operations remain tolerably safe. It can also be performed
on proposed changes to a system or operation to ensure that the risks from any additional
hazards or any impacts on existing hazards, introduced by the change remain acceptably safe.
Safety risk assessment features 8 steps:
1. System / operation description
2. Hazards identification processes
3. Consequence analysis
4. Causal analysis
5. Evaluation of risk
6. Mitigation of risk
7. Approval of residual risk
8. Safety assessment documentation
Fig1: Definition of hazard identification
Risk Controls (Barriers and Mitigation)
A system, activity, action or procedure that is put in place to reduce the risks associated with a
hazard. Mitigation may include:
• elimination of the hazard (preferred),
• reduction in the frequency of the hazard (barriers),
• reduction in the likelihood of the outcomes of the hazard (outcome mitigation),
• reduction of the severity of the outcomes of the hazard (consequence mitigation).
Risk
The combination of the predicted frequency and severity of the consequences of hazard(s)
taking into account all of the potential outcomes.
Safety Risk Management
The identification of hazards associated with the day-to-day operations of an organisation, or
associated with changes to the operations of an organisation; the assessment of the risks
associated with those hazards; and the implementation and management of measures to
reduce those risks to an acceptable level (hazard removal; or the application of barriers and/or
mitigations – i.e. risk control).
The above definitions are illustrated diagrammatically in Figure 1 which is referred to in some
literature as a Bow-Tie diagram. ‘Bow-tie’ also refers to the methodology used to build
such diagram. Some examples of the use of the terminology are also provided in Tables 1 to 4.
The method for building a bow-tie involves asking a structured set of questions in a logical
sequence. The completed Bow-Tie illustrates the hazard, the undesirable event, the safety
events and potential outcomes, and the risk controls put in place to minimise the risk.
Risk management is about controlling risks. This is done by placing barriers to prevent certain
undesirable events from happening. A control can be any measure taken that acts against
some undesirable force or intention, in order to maintain a desired state. In the Bow-Tie
methodology there are preventive or proactive barriers (on the left side of the Undesirable
Event) that prevent the Undesirable Event from happening. There are also corrective or
reactive controls (on the right side of the Undesirable Event) that prevent the Undesirable
Event from resulting into unwanted Outcomes or reduce the consequence severity of the
Outcomes.
3 Hazards identification in Practice
Hazards may be identified through a data-driven (quantitative) methodology or qualitative
process such as discussions, interviews and brainstorming.
3.1 Data Driven Methodologies
In a data-driven approach, hazards are identified and recorded through a systematic process
which allows for traceability and further analysis.
There are various types of recorded observations which may be used to identify hazards.
Sources for hazards identification can be Flight Data Monitoring (FDM), company audits,
staff surveys, hazard reports and others. Investigation and reports of past occurrences
may provide rich material as to existing hazards as well as, alternative to these, hazards which
may arise. For example, an occurrence report may identify the hazard of standing water
affecting the integrity of landing aid equipment at an airport, but through this report other
hazards which may affect this equipment may also be identified.
Furthermore, real-time and non real-time simulations may be used to identify likely hazards
and their interactions. Using simulation modelling it
may be easier to identify potential hazards and their potential outcomes.
3.2 Qualitative Methodologies
Hazards may be identified through a qualitative process, either formal (part of safety
assessment) or informal based on discussions, interviews and brainstorming. Informal
qualitative methodologies are heuristic processes based on expert judgement. They often allow
identifying hazards that other approaches can’t detect. Using both approaches in combination
will provide better and more comprehensive results.
Within published literature, it is recognised that hazards identification must be done
methodically in order to ensure that all areas of operation where hazards may exist have been
identified. It is recommended that among others; design, organisational, work environment
factors, as well as procedures and operating practices are taken into account in the
identification process.
Existing material should be reviewed with the aim of identifying gaps or hazards. The UK CAA
suggests a brainstorming exercise, which will allow participants to
identify hazards within the organisation. The hazard control Toolbox
suggests that the identification of the hazards may be
done by individual or group-based assessors.
The main challenge for individual and group-based brainstorming sessions involves the
identification of hazards which exist but are difficult to think of. Some approaches have been
developed to cover what might be termed ‘unimaginable hazards’.
Unimaginable Hazards
One of the most common ways of identifying hazards other than from occurrence reports is to
conduct functional hazard assessments. In such functional hazard assessments, failures of
prescribed or intended system functions or operational procedures, the operational
consequences of these failures, and the potential effects on the safety of the operation are
identified. It is however a well established fact that some hazards are hard or even impossible
to identify using functional hazard identification sessions. Such hazards are called
unimaginable hazards.
One reason why not all hazards may be identified through a functional approach is that there
may be hazards associated with a system functioning well, for example when operators
become overly reliant on a well-functioning alerting system. Another reason is that some
hazards may not be associated with functional failures, such as those associated with
situational awareness problems. Also, sometimes functions relevant for the safety of the
operations are implicit and go unnoticed, or the available description of the system or
operation involved is otherwise not complete.
This means that, in order to get a complete picture of the relevant hazards, “logical thinking”
from the functional failure point of view must be enhanced by creative input of operational
experts. Such input is obtained through hazard identification brainstorming sessions that are
designed, organised and conducted in a specific manner. Guidance for such hazard
identification brainstorming sessions may be found.
Getting an as complete as possible overview of the relevant hazards is essential of course, as
the risks associated with hazards that go unnoticed, cannot be managed.
4 Specific Tools and Techniques for Hazards Identification
This section provides a summary of a number of tools and techniques that can be used for
hazards identification. The various techniques are described below together with a brief
overview of their advantages and disadvantages.
It should be remembered that any system or operation comprises:
• people;
• procedures;
• equipment; and
• an environment of operation
All these elements must be considered during hazards identification.
Hazards identification techniques require a definition of the System / Operation, its
environment of operation and its interactions to have been completed prior to undertaking the
task (safety risk assessment Step 1: System/Operation description). This System / Operation
definition may take different forms depending on the specific technique and type of system.
The definition may be:
• Functional
• Operational
• Process
• Scenario based
4.1 Brainstorming
Brainstorming is an unbounded but facilitated discussion within a group of experts. A
facilitator prepares prompts or issues ahead of the group session and then encourages
imaginative thinking and discussion between group members during the session. The
facilitator initiates a thread of discussion and there are no rules as to what is in or out of scope
from the subsequent discussion. All contributions are accepted and recorded and no view is
challenged or criticised. This provides an environment in which the experts feel comfortable in
thinking laterally.
Advantages
• Good for identifying new hazards in novel systems.
• Involves all key stakeholders.
• Relatively quick and easy to undertake.
• Can be applied to a wide range of types of systems.
Disadvantages
• Relatively unstructured and therefore not necessarily comprehensive.
• Depends on the expertise and profile of the participants
• May be susceptible to the influence of group dynamics.
• Can rely heavily on the skills of the facilitator for success.
Hazard and Operability (HAZOP) Study
HAZOP is a systematic and structured approach using parameter and deviation guidewords.
The technique relies on a very detailed system description being available for study and
usually involves breaking down the system into well defined subsystems and
functional or process flows between subsystems. Each element of the system is then
subjected to discussion within a multidisciplinary group of experts against the various
combinations of the guidewords and deviations.
The group discussion is facilitated by a Chairman and the results of the discussion recorded by
a Secretary together including any hazards identified when a particular guideword and
deviation combination is discussed. Where a particular guideword and deviation combination
does not produce any hazards, or is not thought credible, this should also be recorded to
demonstrate completeness.
The guidewords and deviations must be prepared in advance by the HAZOP Chairman and may
need to be tailored to the system or operation being studied.
In an aviation context, typical guidewords might include:
• Detection
• Co-ordination
• Notification
• Transmission
• Clearance
• Authorisation
• Selection
• Transcription
• Turn
• Climb
• Descend
• Speed
• Read-back
• Monitoring
• Signage
• Handover
• Supervision
Typical deviations might include:
• Too soon / early
• Too late
• Too much
• Too little
• Too high
• Too low
• Missing
• Twice / repeated
• Out of sequence
• Ambiguous
• Reverse / inverted
Advantages
• Systematic and rigorous.
• Involves interaction of views from multidisciplinary experts.
• Can be applied to a wide range of types of system.
• Creates a detailed and auditable record of the hazards identification process.
Disadvantages
• Requires a considerable amount of preparation.
• Can rely heavily on the skills of the HAZOP Chairman
• Can be time consuming and therefore expensive.
• Can inhibit imaginative thinking and so certain kinds of hazards.
Future Hazards Identification through the FAST method
Identification of future hazards often relies on expert judgement and some sort of
‘instrumented’ brainstorming.
There are only few methods available for future hazards identification. The method developed
by the Future Aviation Safety Team (FAST) is one of these. This team created by the JSSI is
now associated to ECAST, the commercial aviation safety team of the ESSI.
The FAST method (Ref. 8 - FAST method) is a “prognostic” or “predictive” approach
aimed at discovering future hazards arising as a consequence of future changes
introduced inside or outside the global aviation system and of their interaction, and
subsequently develop and implement mitigating actions.
The FAST team has built and maintains a list of 200+ Areas of Changes (AoCs) affecting the
global Aviation and ATM system. This list is used for identification of future hazards.
This list can be augmented by a more specific list of changes identified by the method user
(airline, ANSP, maintenance organisation, manufacturer, authority, etc.) that specifically
affects its activities. A list of local changes is likely to feature proprietary information regarding
for instance new market strategy, new organisation, new staff policy, opening of a new route,
etc., depending on the method user’s profile.
Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA)
FMEA is a ‘bottom up’ technique that is used to consider ways in which the basic
components of a system can fail to perform their design intent. This could either be at
an equipment level or at a functional level. The technique relies on a detailed system
description and considers the ways in which each sub-component of the system could fail to
meet its design intent and what the consequences would be on the overall system.
For each sub-component of a system an FMEA considers:
• All the potential ways that the component could fail.
• The effects that each of these failures would have on the system behaviour.
• The possible causes of the various failure modes.
• How the failures might be mitigated within the system or its environment.
Behaviours at the system level arising from the sub-component failures which have a safety
consequence are thus identified as hazards. The system level at which the analysis is applied
can vary and is determined by the level of detail of the system description used to support the
analysis. Depending on the nature and complexity of the system, the analysis could be
undertaken by an individual system expert or by a team of system experts acting in group
session.
Advantages
• Systematic and rigorous.
• Creates a detailed and auditable record of the hazards identification process.
• Can be applied to a wide range of types of system.
Disadvantages
• Only really considers hazards arising from single point failure modes rather than
combinations of failures.
• Relies on people with detailed system knowledge.
• Can be time consuming and expensive.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)